John Lewis-Stempel presents the story of England, of her history and culture in the words of the people who lived it, from 55 B.C. to 2004 A.D. All the great and influential events are included - from the Gunpowder plot, Boudicca's rebellion, Nelson at Trafalgar, Magna Carta, and two World Wars.
Книга восихтительная. Особенно - первая ее половина, века этак до 18 - читалось на одном дыхании как захватывающий детектив. Лично мне про 19 и 20 вв. было уже не так интересно читать, если честно. :)
Самое главное - тут же не отложить книгу в сторону, едва открыв первую страницу и прочитав там, что во время двух мировых войн именно Англия оказывалась последним оплотом мира. Господи, а 20 миллионов погибших русских это что, по вашему? Несчастный случай? Снобизм и высокомерие, которыми веет от это
Книга восихтительная. Особенно - первая ее половина, века этак до 18 - читалось на одном дыхании как захватывающий детектив. Лично мне про 19 и 20 вв. было уже не так интересно читать, если честно. :)
Самое главное - тут же не отложить книгу в сторону, едва открыв первую страницу и прочитав там, что во время двух мировых войн именно Англия оказывалась последним оплотом мира. Господи, а 20 миллионов погибших русских это что, по вашему? Несчастный случай? Снобизм и высокомерие, которыми веет от этого предложения чуть было не заставили меня вычеркнуть его черным маркером с глаз долой. Но, если себя пересилить, от дальнешего чтения получаешь только удовольствие.
Самый цимус в книге - это то, что материалы написаны не рукой одного историка в профессиональном изложении, а написаны разными людьми - очевидцами тех событий. Они видели все своими глазами и описали все честно, хотя и не масштабно, хотя и не представляя еще, какое значение примет этот эпизод для дальнейшей истории. По ходу чтения иногда удивляло, с какой скупостью описывали катастрофы (тот же пожар в Лондоне 1666 года) или жестокость правителей к своим подчиненным и наоборот, и с какой детальностью и величием описывали жестокие битвы. К сожалению, на мой взгляд, книге не хватает чуть-чуть наглядности. Очень бы порадовала таблица, на которой были бы представлены все правившие на Альбионе короли и королевы - мне так и не удалось проследить, когда и какими путями одна династия сменяла другую %) Очень понравились зарисовки о нравах, погоде, научных открытиях, праздниках разных эпох - они погружали в неповторимую атмосферу :)
...more
This is a book that my wife picked up for me several years ago during her first visit to England. I was still active duty Air Force and stationed in Germany and was unable to get away for that trip although was fortunate enough to be able to go the next year.
This book, England, The Autobiography, edited by John Lewis-Stemple, is a collection of first-hand accounts of English history written by English men and women from all walks of life, some famous and some not. As such, most of the accounts a
This is a book that my wife picked up for me several years ago during her first visit to England. I was still active duty Air Force and stationed in Germany and was unable to get away for that trip although was fortunate enough to be able to go the next year.
This book, England, The Autobiography, edited by John Lewis-Stemple, is a collection of first-hand accounts of English history written by English men and women from all walks of life, some famous and some not. As such, most of the accounts are quite interesting, while others are less so. They are presented chronologically, beginning at 55 BC with an account written by Julius Caesar of his invasion and traversing history all the way to its publication date in 2005 with an account of "England Wins Ashes, the Oval, London." In between there are a hundred or so sketches summarizing 2000 years of English history, from those that were there.
I found most of these sketches to be very interesting, whether it's from the point of view of a Saxon warrior at the Battle of Maldon in 991, or about the Peasants' Revolt in 1381, or a piece by Winston Churchill during WWII, or The Beatles in Performance at the Cavern Club in Liverpool in 1961 by none other than Brian Epstein. Taken all together, these sketches provide a nice overview of English history for somebody who is already at least partially familiar with that history. If this is the first book ever picked up on the subject I don't think it would go very far in educating somebody about it...it's just too little detail about too many events, and each event is only addressed once, often by somebody who has a strong bias one way or the other. But as a companion book to a library of history, this is a fascinating read and makes me want to search out other such books for other countries/cultures.
...more
Lewis-Stemple’s book was fantastic to read. Jam packed with accounts covering every major event in English history. Lewis-Stemple uses a huge variety of sources from political leaders, journalists and ruling monarchs to normal everyday people. He misleads his reader though by billing his work as an ‘autobiography’. There are not as many ‘eye-witnesses’ as he would lead you to believe, more ‘word-of-mouth’ stories.
He picked a great selection of events, however because there are so many, some of t
Lewis-Stemple’s book was fantastic to read. Jam packed with accounts covering every major event in English history. Lewis-Stemple uses a huge variety of sources from political leaders, journalists and ruling monarchs to normal everyday people. He misleads his reader though by billing his work as an ‘autobiography’. There are not as many ‘eye-witnesses’ as he would lead you to believe, more ‘word-of-mouth’ stories.
He picked a great selection of events, however because there are so many, some of the extracts verged on boring but that’s understandable; readers will be interested in different areas. He also tries hard to successfully link each extract together to keep the flow and help novices in history follow the chronological path. He does this successfully in the beginning but I found that as the book got further on, he attempted this less and less. I’m not sure whether it was because these were more recent events and he expected the reader to have known of them or he was just finding it tiresome.
This book is perfect for those who want to read about the experience of England in less than 500 pages but still have it packed with information, a lot of it previously unknown.
...more
With the long, interesting history that England has, this could have easily spanned twenty volumes.
As it stands though, the author did well to choose some well known and some lesser known parts of our country's fascinating past.
It is the first hand accounts that make it though. From peasants to kings and queens. Documented in their own hand, after witnessing key events with their own eyes.
I enjoyed this book so much, that I began reading it again almost instantly! A very good collation of primary sources to tell the history of England in an almost fictitious prose. Very informative to the novice and the historian with a variety of sources which range in reliability.