He set his star by a simple motto: duty, honor,country. Only rarely does history grant a singleindividual the ability, personal charisma, moralforce, and intelligence to command the respect,admiration, and affection of an entire nation. But sucha man is General H. Norman Schwarzkopf, commanderof the Allied Forces in the Gulf War. Now, in thisrefreshingly candid and typical
He set his star by a simple motto: duty, honor, country. Only rarely does history grant a single individual the ability, personal charisma, moral force, and intelligence to command the respect, admiration, and affection of an entire nation. But such a man is General H. Norman Schwarzkopf, commander of the Allied Forces in the Gulf War. Now, in this refreshingly candid and typically outspoken autobiography, General Schwarzkopf reviews his remarkable life and career: the events, the adventures, and the emotions that molded the character and shaped the beliefs of this uniquely distinguished American leader.
...more
Paperback
,
640 pages
Published
September 1st 1993
by Bantam
(first published 1992)
الكتاب يتحدث عن قائد قوات التحالف في حرب الخليج 1991، ضد عراق صدام حسين، لتحرير الكويت. يتحدث الكتاب عن دور نورمان شوارتزكوف (أثار البعض بأنه من يهود ألمانيا، علما أن الكتاب لم يتحدث عن ديانته بأي شيء) عن نشأته في ويست بوينت (المدرسة العسكرية للأمريكان، على غرار سانت هريست في بريطانيا) وكيف شارك في حرب الخليج، وكيف تعامل مع الأمير خالد بن سلطان، القائد السعودي للجيش..فقد كان في بعض الأوقات على خلاف معه.
الكتاب في رأيي تمت تشويه ترجمته عمدا والله أعلم. فخالد بن سلطان نفى في كتابه(مقاتل من الصحراء)
الكتاب يتحدث عن قائد قوات التحالف في حرب الخليج 1991، ضد عراق صدام حسين، لتحرير الكويت. يتحدث الكتاب عن دور نورمان شوارتزكوف (أثار البعض بأنه من يهود ألمانيا، علما أن الكتاب لم يتحدث عن ديانته بأي شيء) عن نشأته في ويست بوينت (المدرسة العسكرية للأمريكان، على غرار سانت هريست في بريطانيا) وكيف شارك في حرب الخليج، وكيف تعامل مع الأمير خالد بن سلطان، القائد السعودي للجيش..فقد كان في بعض الأوقات على خلاف معه.
الكتاب في رأيي تمت تشويه ترجمته عمدا والله أعلم. فخالد بن سلطان نفى في كتابه(مقاتل من الصحراء) حوارا ، زعم فيه نورمان في كتابه بأن خالد بن سلطان رفض طباعة تي شيرتات تحمل خريطة السعودية، بحجة أن العدو العراقي قد يستفيد من هذه التي شيرتات في الحرب بمعرفة مواقع المدن!!. أقول بأن القصة تلك لم أجدها في كتاب شوارتزكوف. فهذا يعني أحد أمرين، إما أن خالد بن سلطان قد أخطأ في عزو القصة إلى كتاب شوارتزكوف، وإما أن الترجمة العربية للكتاب قد حذفت القصة (وهو ما أرجحه)..هذا إذا افترضنا صحة نسبة هذا المزعم إلى القائد العسكري الأمريكي شوارتزكوف.
في الكتاب يتحدث الكتاب أيضا عن مواقف للسعودية حول اختلاف العادات والثقافات. فالأمريكان كانوا أكثر لباقة من الفرنسيين. إذ أدى جورج بوش الأب صلاة عيد الشكر في بارجة أمريكية في عرض الخليج العربي، حتى لا يحرج السعوديين في موضوع إقامة مراسم دينية على أراضيها، ولم يسمحوا بتداول المجلات الإباحية لعناصر الجيش الأمريكي. في حين أن الفرنسيين توترت علاقاتهم مع السعوديين، بسبب عدم سماح السعوديين لفرقة فرنسية راقصة مع فتيات بالدخول للأراضي السعودية للترفيه عن الجنود الفرنسيين المشاركين بالحرب. وقد قرأت في كتاب (حرب الخليج دفعتني للاستقالة) بأن السفير أو القادئ العسكري الفرنسي قد تجاهل دعوة للغداء مع الأمير سلطان، بسبب هذالموقف!
شيء آخر أشار إليه محمد حسنين هيكل بالتصريح، ولم يتحدث عنه خالد بن سلطان وشواتزكوف إلا بالتلميح (وفق الترجمة العربية التي لدي). وهي أن شوانزكوف اعترض قبل دخوله إلى الأراضي السعودية على وجود خالد بن سلطان قائدا.. فمن له كلمة الفصل في شأن جيش التحالف إذا اختلفوا؟ جاء الحل كما قال هيكل ( على الطريقة العربية) بأن الأراضي السعودية، الفصل فيها لخالد بن سلطان، وما كان خارج الحدود السعودية فالفصل فيها للأمريكان. وقد جاء تحرير مدينة الخفجي السعودية كقرينة تؤكد صحة ما أشار إليه هيكل، فقد أسند تحرير المدينة إلى قوات الحرس الوطني السعودي، بالتعاون مع الجيش القطري، بقيادة خالد بن سلطان، وقد تحدث نورمان شواتزكوف عن هذا بما يدل على أنه كان بعيدا عن مسرح عمليات معركة التحرير.
هناك معركة (لم يشر إليها في هذا الكتاب)كادت أن تكون فيها الغلبة للعراقيين، داخل الأراضي العراقية، ولم أقرأ عنها سوى في مصدر واحد، ومشكوك في مصداقيته. تسمى بمعركة الأطواق..حيث طوق الأمريكان والعراقيين بعضهم البعض عدة مرات، حتى كادت أن تستلم القوات الأمريكية، إلى أن جاءتهم النجدة من قوات فرنسية وبريطانية
بعيدا عن معركة نورمان، كانت السعودية مسرحا للتفكر بين الإسلاميين. بين من يرى أن السعودية قد فعلت منكرا بالاستعانة بالقوات الأجنبية، ويجب على الداعية الإنكار عليهم، وبين من يفكر في شكل العلاقة بين الراعي والرعية، لأسباب يطول شرحها،و بين فرقة سميت لاحقا بالجامية ظهرت آنذاك مؤيدة تأييدا مطلقا لسياسات الحكومة، لتمهد الطريق أمام جيل من الأذناب، يُلبس النفاق لباسا سلفيا. فتساوى حينها غازي الياور مع الأخ العقيد معمر، مع غيره. فكلهم ولاة أمر تجب طاعتهم!!
كثيرون من الإسلاميين خارج السعودية غضبوا من الشيخ ابن باز لأنه أجاز الاستعانة بالقوات الغربية في حربهم ضد صدام. البعض كان يخاف العدو القريب، كابن باز، والبعض مشغول بالعدو البعيد (الأمريكي) كالشيخ سفر الحوالي، والبعض كان يرى حرمة هذا الفعل أيا كانت الحاجة للغرب، كالشيخ الألباني. وأيا يكن الرأي، فإن الفقيه كما قال ابن تيمية، ليس من يعرف الخير من الشر، بل هو من يعرف خير الخيرين، وشر الشرين. فالمسألة ليست نصا يدرس، بقدر ما هو نظر في حال المستعين والمستعان به.
حرب الخليج كشفت مواقف بعض الإسلاميين وعقلياتهم..وربما كانت تلك المواقف الطلقة الأخيرة بين الحكومة السعودية وبينهم، كما جرى مع جماعة الإخوان المسلمين، الذين استنكروا على السعوديين بشدة، استعانتهم بالغرب، وربما بلطف ولين، استنكروا غزو الكويت..هذا إن لم يؤيدوا الغزو. كما كشفت أيضا عن (نظام عالمي جديد) يتزعمه قطب واحد، هي أمريكا، تأمر فتطاع...إذ لم تستطع روسيا السوفيتية أن تفعل للعراق شيئا يذكر.. وهي (أي أمريكا) التي يكتب في شأنها حاليا،في صحافة الغرب، كالإيكونوميست والإنديبيندنت، بأنها لم تعد تلك القوة العظمى بدليل عدم قدرتهم على حسم ملف الثورة السورية.
حرب الخليج عاصرتها وكان عمري 12 تقريبا..كان الجميع يحمل جهاز مذياع صغير، مدار على إذاعة لندن، أو مونتي كارلو آنذاك..وكانت الحوارات السائدة بين العامة آنذاك عن مدى مفعول مضاد الصواريخ الأرضية باترويت، على منازلنا، فمنا من يقول اهتزت النوافذ شيئا قليلا، ومنهم من يقول اهتز المبنى كله من صوت الصاروخ. ولا ننس الفرز السياسي للجنسيات من المجتمع السعودي آنذاك وماذا فعلت بالعمالة الوافدة..ولكنها ولله الحمد لم تكبر وتتفاقم بسبب سرعة الحسم العسكري.
...more
I really enjoyed learning the history of one of the recent commanders in theater. Especially as it pertains to the Middle East. General Schwarzkopf was very simple in detailing his experience and progression through the army. He did not have, or appear to have, political alliances or military agendas he just had the desire to serve his country and serve his soldiers. He was a soldier's soldier. I marveled at the account of desert shield and the back and forth with Washington I executing that pla
I really enjoyed learning the history of one of the recent commanders in theater. Especially as it pertains to the Middle East. General Schwarzkopf was very simple in detailing his experience and progression through the army. He did not have, or appear to have, political alliances or military agendas he just had the desire to serve his country and serve his soldiers. He was a soldier's soldier. I marveled at the account of desert shield and the back and forth with Washington I executing that plan and Desert Storm. Very intriguing recent history worth recommendation.
...more
I served with General Schwarzkopf in the 24th Infantry division and during Desert Shield/Desert Storm. This book left me with a better understanding of how we fought the war. A must read for all particular the military members. I retired in 1992 after 27 years as a Command Sergeants Major. It was a pleasure to have served under General Schwarzkopf.
Bio of "Stormin' Norman" Schwarzkopf. I enjoyed this book immensely and came away with great respect for the man. Whether you agree with his politics is almost irrelevant here as he has had such an interesting military career that you want to keep reading about him.
"...I am convinced that had a decision been made to invade all of Iraq and capture Baghdad...the only forces that would have participated in those military actions would have been British and American. Even the French would have withd
Bio of "Stormin' Norman" Schwarzkopf. I enjoyed this book immensely and came away with great respect for the man. Whether you agree with his politics is almost irrelevant here as he has had such an interesting military career that you want to keep reading about him.
"...I am convinced that had a decision been made to invade all of Iraq and capture Baghdad...the only forces that would have participated in those military actions would have been British and American. Even the French would have withdrawn from the coalition. Had the US and the UK gone on alone to capture Baghdad, under the provisions of the Geneva and Hague conventions we would have been considered occupying powers and therefore would have been responsible for all the costs of maintaining and restoring government, education, and other services for the people of Iraq. From the brief time we did spend occupying Iraqi territory after the war, I am certain that had we taken all of Iraq, we would have been like the dinosaur in the tar pit--we would still be there, and we, not the UN, would be bearing the costs of that occupation."
Most prophetic words.
...more
If you want to read of a person with great leadership qualities, this is one definitely worth picking up.
General H. Norman Schwarzkopf, a West Point graduate who experienced the lows of the Vietnam War and participated in the US military's transformation in the 1980s, just in time for the end of the Cold War, exemplified the qualities of integrity, sagacity, courage, and in-your-face assertiveness that would serve the world well.
Kuwait may have been extravagant and arrogant in its splurging of
If you want to read of a person with great leadership qualities, this is one definitely worth picking up.
General H. Norman Schwarzkopf, a West Point graduate who experienced the lows of the Vietnam War and participated in the US military's transformation in the 1980s, just in time for the end of the Cold War, exemplified the qualities of integrity, sagacity, courage, and in-your-face assertiveness that would serve the world well.
Kuwait may have been extravagant and arrogant in its splurging of oil wealth and may have deserved a wallop, but I bet Saddam Hussein didn't know what hit him when the Allies eventually stood up to Iraq's invasion of that tiny country in 1990. And did Gen. Schwarzkopf and the Allies kick his sorry rearend.
...more
This is the second time I have read this book. Since the first time there have been many upheavals globally, including financial and corporate mismanagement on a far reaching scale. When you see how General S. managed a coalition comprising many cultures, his diplomacy and civility with world leaders and his concerns for the 'working man' under his command it makes you think about the integrity and leadership instilled in the military and how it could be best utilized across our government and c
This is the second time I have read this book. Since the first time there have been many upheavals globally, including financial and corporate mismanagement on a far reaching scale. When you see how General S. managed a coalition comprising many cultures, his diplomacy and civility with world leaders and his concerns for the 'working man' under his command it makes you think about the integrity and leadership instilled in the military and how it could be best utilized across our government and corporate institutions! A great leader, top soldier and wonderful family Man.
...more
I read this book when I was a young Private stationed in 2ND MP, 2ND ID as a medic. I drew inspiration and character greatly from "It Doesn't Take a Hero". It is nearly 2 decades later. In fact, I just retired from the Army! I just want to say "Thank YOU" General "Stormin'" Norman Schwarzkopf. In so many circumstances, instances, and challenges, your words and spirit were always with me. Most recently, talking candidly with my Command Sergeant Major, I asked him if he felt like he was Gen Colin
I read this book when I was a young Private stationed in 2ND MP, 2ND ID as a medic. I drew inspiration and character greatly from "It Doesn't Take a Hero". It is nearly 2 decades later. In fact, I just retired from the Army! I just want to say "Thank YOU" General "Stormin'" Norman Schwarzkopf. In so many circumstances, instances, and challenges, your words and spirit were always with me. Most recently, talking candidly with my Command Sergeant Major, I asked him if he felt like he was Gen Colin Powell or Gen Norman Schwarzkopf. I knew the answer myself, but CSM said he had read both books, so I knew he would understand the point I was trying to make. I am a GEN Schwarzkopf. I will always take the hard right and fight for what is right, not what is politically acceptable. A wise NCO once told me "Never let mediocrity set the standard!" and I have preached this to my subordinates over and over through the years. The military, the government, and the World needs more Gen Schwarzkopfs!
...more
He set his star by a simple motto: duty, honor, country. Only rarely does history grant a single individual the ability, personal charisma, moral force, and intelligence to command the respect, admiration, and affection of an entire nation. But such a man is General H. Norman Schwarzkopf, commander of the Allied Forces in the Gulf War. Now, in this refreshingly candid and typically outspoken autobiography, General Schwarzkopf reviews his remarkable life and career: the events, the adventures, an
He set his star by a simple motto: duty, honor, country. Only rarely does history grant a single individual the ability, personal charisma, moral force, and intelligence to command the respect, admiration, and affection of an entire nation. But such a man is General H. Norman Schwarzkopf, commander of the Allied Forces in the Gulf War. Now, in this refreshingly candid and typically outspoken autobiography, General Schwarzkopf reviews his remarkable life and career: the events, the adventures, and the emotions that molded the character and shaped the beliefs of this uniquely distinguished American leader.
...more
This had everything for the military historian. It started with Iran during WWII, described West Point in the early 50's, and the change in Army culture from the mid 50's until 1991. In this vast sweep, General Schwarzkopf described most everything from garrison leadership following the Korean War, to the formation of TRADOC, to the post Soviet era when the US was adapting to being the world's last superpower. All of this, plus first person accounting from two tours in the Vietnamese jungles, th
This had everything for the military historian. It started with Iran during WWII, described West Point in the early 50's, and the change in Army culture from the mid 50's until 1991. In this vast sweep, General Schwarzkopf described most everything from garrison leadership following the Korean War, to the formation of TRADOC, to the post Soviet era when the US was adapting to being the world's last superpower. All of this, plus first person accounting from two tours in the Vietnamese jungles, the entire Grenada mission, and oh yeah, most anything you needed to know about the Gulf War. I wish I'd read this while I was still on active duty because I think I would have been a better leader as a result. Through it all, his strength was rooted in his family, a love magnified in the courageous telling of his mother's struggle with alcohol addiction. General Schwarzkopf seemed destined to be at the focal point of history as there were myriad close calls and advantageous twists in his rise to the top post in Central Command, just as the world needed him. His years living in Iran with his father following WWII making him the perfect man at the perfect time.
This should be required reading for every modern soldier, but is certainly an eye opening read for any American.
...more
I first read this book in 1995. I have read it once since. "It Doesn’t Take a Hero" by H. Norman Schwarzkopf takes its title from a quote Schwarzkopf gave during an interview with Barbara Walters in 1991; "It Doesn’t Take a Hero to order men into battle. It takes a hero to be one of those men who goes into battle."
First, I must admit I am a Schwarzkopf fan. He commanded the 1st Brigade, 9th Infantry Division as a colonel while I was serving as a 1LT in the 9th Division. His third child (son) was
I first read this book in 1995. I have read it once since. "It Doesn’t Take a Hero" by H. Norman Schwarzkopf takes its title from a quote Schwarzkopf gave during an interview with Barbara Walters in 1991; "It Doesn’t Take a Hero to order men into battle. It takes a hero to be one of those men who goes into battle."
First, I must admit I am a Schwarzkopf fan. He commanded the 1st Brigade, 9th Infantry Division as a colonel while I was serving as a 1LT in the 9th Division. His third child (son) was born about two hours after my first son at Madigan Army General Hospital. We spent time in the Army hospital delivery room together. Our wives were in beds besides each other in the hospital ward. We were on a first name basis. He called me lieutenant and I called him sir. Prior to his arrival at Fort Lewis he had been the assistant commander of the 172nd Infantry Brigade (Alaska Brigade). The 172nd Infantry Brigade’s commander he served under was Major General Willard (Will) Latham who Schwarzkopf called the toughest general in the US Army. I have been an acquaintance of MG Latham’s for 35 years. Latham's son was a class mate of mine at University of Texas at Arlington (UT Arlington). Will Latham and I are active members of the Corps of Cadet Alumni Council Board at the UT Arlington. I have discussed Schwarzkopf and Schwarzkopf’s book with Latham. I also am a contributor to the Wikipedia article H. Norman Schwarzkopf.
Schwarzkopf came from an upper middle class family, his father was a West Point graduate, head of the New Jersey state police (who later led the hunt for the Lindbergh kidnappers), and served President Roosevelt on a special assignment in Iran. They lived in the best house in their town, and even employed a maid, but there was a dark family secret... his mother's alcoholism. His experiences in the Middle East in Iran as a young man, where he lived with his general father, gave him a unique insight into the Arab world that served him personally, and the coalition as a whole. He went to boarding schools in the middle-east and in Switzerland. This helped him develop the cultural understanding and build some relationships that he would later call on during the Gulf War.
The part of the book that deals with his duties in Vietnam is interesting. He expresses the popular hindsight viewpoint against the stupidity and arrogance of the politicians and 'Brass' who ordered young men to lay down their lives in that far away land for no good reason. He became convinced that he had to do something to change the army from within; it was either that or he resigns his commission.
His role in leading the rescue of the medical students in Grenada is extremely interesting. It provided him with lessons that were applied during the Gulf War.
The most interesting part of the book is his telling of the Gulf War, Desert Storm. It is probably true to say that without "Stormin'" Norman, there wouldn't have been a, successful, Gulf War. He was able to play on the links his father had with Arab Royalty, and then forged his own links with the current Saudi Royal Family, working with Crown Princes on a first name basis to get things done, everything from releasing endless millions of dollars in payments to the US - what is the daily rental on an aircraft carrier?! - to arranging for "tent cities" to be erected to shield the incoming troops from the scorching desert sun.
The most interesting aspect of the Gulf War section was the politics of the coalition, especially in the Arab world, something that was almost completely missing in Colin Powell's memoir. In this crucial, although mostly unknown area of the War, Schwarzkopf's experiences in the Middle East were invaluable. Middle Eastern politics are a lethal mine field at the best of times - us Brits have had our fingers burnt on more than one occasion over the years! - and pouring hundreds of thousands of free thinking, free drinking, Western troops of endless religious and moral persuasions into the autocracy that is the kingdom of Saudi Arabia, should have been a recipe for utter disaster!
Schwarzkopf's deft handling of the endless 'difficulties' involving religious services, the consumption of alcohol, the reading of magazines of dubious 'artistic' merit, even the receiving of Christmas cards and the erection of Christmas decorations, were handled with a skill and subtlety that one would not have thought a mere 'soldier' possible. And then of course there was the Israeli question. The one thing above all else that would have blown the coalition apart would have been Israel attacking Iraq in retaliation for the Scuds that fell on Israeli territory. Although much of the efforts to keep Israel out of the action were handled direct from Washington, Schwarzkopf's handling of the Saudi's in particular, on the ground as it were was masterful.
"It Doesn’t Take a Hero" is a fascinating tale, a real inspiration; it shows what one man can achieve through clear thinking, a positive attitude, boundless enthusiasm, and a profound love, not only of his own country, but of mankind. I would recommend it highly. Read and reviewed by Jimmie A. Kepler.
...more
The most interesting aspect of this work is that it is a primary source written in 1992 about Iraq. There is not a single mention of Al Qaeda or any other Islamic terrorist group in the entire book; the closest mention is the 1983 attack in Beirut, brought up only because Schwarzkopf was concerned about Iraq committing a similar attack on US forces in Saudi Arabia. The world has changed quite a bit since then and the events of this book played no small role in creating that change. Our role in t
The most interesting aspect of this work is that it is a primary source written in 1992 about Iraq. There is not a single mention of Al Qaeda or any other Islamic terrorist group in the entire book; the closest mention is the 1983 attack in Beirut, brought up only because Schwarzkopf was concerned about Iraq committing a similar attack on US forces in Saudi Arabia. The world has changed quite a bit since then and the events of this book played no small role in creating that change. Our role in the Middle East was almost non-existent prior to the Gulf War; CENTCOM's role was, of all things, to prevent a Soviet invasion of Iran. Desert Storm changed our relationship with this region. Half a million Western troops were suddenly in the holiest region of the world to Islam, which unfortunately also happens to be one of the most important economic regions for the entire world economy. An Arab force was defeated by a staunch ally of Israel who then kept thousands of troops in Saudi Arabia and Kuwait to defend against possible future aggression by Saddam.
Al Qaeda was not on our radar screen prior to this conflict and I've never seen any indication that we were a major concern of theirs prior to Saddam's invasion of Kuwait. Saddam's aggression was a catalyst that brought Islamic fundamentalists and western powers into closer contact with catastrophic results. I've never said and never believed Saddam Hussein had a direct role in 9/11, but his decisions destabilizing the Middle East helped put us on that road.
The book itself is certainly worth picking up. I learned quite a bit about how the U.S. Army worked and perhaps still works. It is a large organization that can be tripped up by the same plagues suffered by any bureaucracy. Autobiographies always have to be read with a grain of salt, as people tend to wash over faults and expound upon successes. Should be compared to Fred Franks' book on the VII Corps' role; given hindsight, I think Franks performed admirably and that rushing forward piecemeal could have been dangerous in the face of the Republican Guard. I doubt destroying another division would have made much of a difference (again, I have the advantage of hindsight). Schwarzkopf himself ends by saying he was overly harsh with VII Corps' performance and it must be kept in mind that the book is recording his thoughts at the time rather than as he sees them in retrospect, though one still gets the feeling Stormin' Norman wished Franks had more get up and go.
...more
I liked this a lot. I know that a lot of people felt that the Gulf War had broke the curse of the "Vietnam Syndrome" and for that reason embraced Norman Schwarzkopf as a hero. Not his evaluation of himself though. The title comes from an interview he gave to Barbara Walters:
It Doesn’t Take a Hero to order men into battle. It takes a hero to be one of those men who goes into battle.
I found it fascinating to hear his account of his career in the military. His experience in Vietnam and the lesson
I liked this a lot. I know that a lot of people felt that the Gulf War had broke the curse of the "Vietnam Syndrome" and for that reason embraced Norman Schwarzkopf as a hero. Not his evaluation of himself though. The title comes from an interview he gave to Barbara Walters:
It Doesn’t Take a Hero to order men into battle. It takes a hero to be one of those men who goes into battle.
I found it fascinating to hear his account of his career in the military. His experience in Vietnam and the lessons he drew from it was interesting--but what made this account particularly valuable was his story of building the coalition to successfully prosecute the Gulf War. Given his long experience with the Middle East, I think the story and his insights into the region are still important today.
...more
This is a well-written account of the Gulf War. When diplomacy fails, as it did after Iraq's invasion of Kuwait, the politicians must step aside and allow the military to do its job. This book is a good example of that process.
I gave this book 5 stars,not because it is a classic, but because I found General Schwarzkopf's life and military career particularly interesting, candid and not sugar-coated, and compelling. He vividly illustrates some powerful life lessons that are valuable to any young person in lending perspective on one's life work. One is the value of the "network" and the "small world" syndrome. Another is the value of locating and retaining good mentors. Yet another is the possibility for overcoming amon
I gave this book 5 stars,not because it is a classic, but because I found General Schwarzkopf's life and military career particularly interesting, candid and not sugar-coated, and compelling. He vividly illustrates some powerful life lessons that are valuable to any young person in lending perspective on one's life work. One is the value of the "network" and the "small world" syndrome. Another is the value of locating and retaining good mentors. Yet another is the possibility for overcoming among children of alcoholic parents. A really great story told carefully, very readably by a real hero who has gotten that heroes come from common humanity, no pedigree required. Although he had one. Again, not destined to become a "classic", but well worth the read.
...more
I have always admired this General. I liked this book very much. He has my total respect. He always put his country first and made decisions that were very difficult in the Middle East. He has been much admired by his soldiers.
Really enjoyed this insightful autobiography about an enigmatic patriot. It did fail to show any of his faults/mistakes, but the inner look at the bureaucracy of the Army was worth the publishing cost alone.
The whole book was really potraying Schwartzkopf as a hero. The book does speak to effective leadership styles. He speaks to the leadership styles of various commanding styles of his commanding officers as he came up the ranks. The best quote of the book came when as a four star general he lead Desert Storm. "I was absolutely dependent on the individual skills, temperaments, and justment of my generals...." "I could establish a framework and convey my intentions and the spirit in which I wanted
The whole book was really potraying Schwartzkopf as a hero. The book does speak to effective leadership styles. He speaks to the leadership styles of various commanding styles of his commanding officers as he came up the ranks. The best quote of the book came when as a four star general he lead Desert Storm. "I was absolutely dependent on the individual skills, temperaments, and justment of my generals...." "I could establish a framework and convey my intentions and the spirit in which I wanted the campaign carried out..." Schwartzkoft does addmit to his mistake in allowing Sadam Hussein keep his helicopters after the war. This allowed Hussein to futher oppress his people.
...more
Did you ever wonder if a spectacular military success was the result of leadership or simply an aligning of the stars?
The Gulf War (Operation Desert Storm) was one of the most successful military operations (at 100 hours, its difficult to call it a campaign) of all time. How much was due to Schwarzkopf?
A student and a warrior and the master of numerous languages, "Stormin' Norman" was an anomaly in the military. A Vietnam combat veteran, he learned the hard lessons of war the hard way. All is r
Did you ever wonder if a spectacular military success was the result of leadership or simply an aligning of the stars?
The Gulf War (Operation Desert Storm) was one of the most successful military operations (at 100 hours, its difficult to call it a campaign) of all time. How much was due to Schwarzkopf?
A student and a warrior and the master of numerous languages, "Stormin' Norman" was an anomaly in the military. A Vietnam combat veteran, he learned the hard lessons of war the hard way. All is revealed in It Doesn't Take a Hero and it is definitely worth the time and money to read about the man and how the deed was done.
Then you won’t have to wonder...you will know!
...more
left me in awe of the logistical goals reached by the planners to stage and implement Desert Storm
oh to be 9 years old growing up in Tehran as Norman did
I'm reading this for a potential film idea and am enjoying it in many unsuspected ways. He spent a portion of his childhood in Iran while his father was there building up the Shah's forces and I was interested to read his descriptions of the experience.
Also, the connection between his mother's alcoholism and his need for the structure of the military he writes about is fascinating to me. It makes me want to read the biographies of more people in power whose politics/worldview I think I disagree
I'm reading this for a potential film idea and am enjoying it in many unsuspected ways. He spent a portion of his childhood in Iran while his father was there building up the Shah's forces and I was interested to read his descriptions of the experience.
Also, the connection between his mother's alcoholism and his need for the structure of the military he writes about is fascinating to me. It makes me want to read the biographies of more people in power whose politics/worldview I think I disagree with and learn to understand them with more complexity, and maybe even a little compassion.
...more
Like a lot of books about famous people, it's more interesting to me in the beginning learning how they grew up and their earlier life and how it made them suited for the things we know about from history. He wrote it only a year after the 1991 Gulf War, so I didn't get any idea what else he did or thought about in retirement. Good first hand telling of how the Army of the 50's and 60's was pretty bad due to no one holding officers accountable for their unit's readiness for war
Good book overall.
Like a lot of books about famous people, it's more interesting to me in the beginning learning how they grew up and their earlier life and how it made them suited for the things we know about from history. He wrote it only a year after the 1991 Gulf War, so I didn't get any idea what else he did or thought about in retirement. Good first hand telling of how the Army of the 50's and 60's was pretty bad due to no one holding officers accountable for their unit's readiness for war.
...more
This book's second half gets a bit technical, but it was a good read if only to read about a war that I only remember from snippets on the news as a boy. Schwarzkopf used lessons he learned personally in Vietnam throughout his military career and seems like a commander who really cared.
A few passages in the book indicate that he had an inkling that another war would be fought for Mesopotamia, and it was written in 1992 after he retired from the Army. A good read for those who enjoy military hist
This book's second half gets a bit technical, but it was a good read if only to read about a war that I only remember from snippets on the news as a boy. Schwarzkopf used lessons he learned personally in Vietnam throughout his military career and seems like a commander who really cared.
A few passages in the book indicate that he had an inkling that another war would be fought for Mesopotamia, and it was written in 1992 after he retired from the Army. A good read for those who enjoy military history.
...more
Good source for the actual run-up and campaign for Desert Storm, but I would recommend balancing it with other accounts. Very good read for anyone interested in leadership development. I was in the same area in his Vietnam service (and possibly the same minefield at one time) and agree with his comments on the varied levels of leadership in the AO. As does Colin Powell, who overlapped in Americal Division.
I liked this book much more than Collin Powell's book. It just seems more honest and less self serving, General Schwartzkopf admits mistakes, and positions he has taken for political reasons. It makes a very interesting read about decision making in the higher ranks of the military. If you've read Powell's book, you'd like this one, and if you haven't, read it after this as a great supplement.
Born in Trenton, New Jersey, Schwarzkopf grew up in the United States and later in Iran. He was accepted into the United States Military Academy at West Point and was commissioned as a Second Lieutenant in the United States Army in 1956. After a number of initial training programs, Schwarzkopf interrupted a stint as an academy teacher, and served in the Vietnam War first as an adviser to the South
Born in Trenton, New Jersey, Schwarzkopf grew up in the United States and later in Iran. He was accepted into the United States Military Academy at West Point and was commissioned as a Second Lieutenant in the United States Army in 1956. After a number of initial training programs, Schwarzkopf interrupted a stint as an academy teacher, and served in the Vietnam War first as an adviser to the South Vietnamese Army and later as a battalion commander. Schwarzkopf was highly decorated in Vietnam, being awarded three Silver Star Medals, two Purple Hearts, and the Legion of Merit. Rising through the ranks after the conflict, he later commanded the U.S. 24th Infantry Division and was one of the commanders of the Invasion of Grenada in 1983.
Assuming command of United States Central Command in 1988, Schwarzkopf was called on to respond to the Invasion of Kuwait in 1990 by the forces of Iraq under Saddam Hussein. Initially tasked with defending Saudi Arabia from Iraqi aggression, Schwarzkopf's command eventually grew to an international force of over 750,000 troops. After diplomatic relations broke down, he planned and led Operation Desert Storm—an extended air campaign followed by a highly successful 100-hour ground offensive—which destroyed the Iraqi Army and liberated Kuwait in early 1991. Highly regarded for these exploits, Schwarzkopf became a national hero and was presented with many military honors for what historians termed one of the most successful campaigns in U.S. military history.
Schwarzkopf retired shortly after the end of the war and undertook a number of philanthropic ventures, only occasionally stepping into the political spotlight before his death from complications of pneumonia in late 2012. Leaving a legacy as a hard-driving military commander with a strong temper, Schwarzkopf was nonetheless considered an exceptional leader by biographers and was noted for his abilities as a military diplomat and in dealing with the press.
...more