As a young law graduate in Sialkot (now in Pakistan), Kuldip Nayar witnessed at first hand the collapse of trust between Hindus and Muslims who were living together for generations, and like multitude of population he was forced to migrate to Delhi across the blood-stained plains of Punjab. From his perilous journey to a new country and to his first job as a young journali
As a young law graduate in Sialkot (now in Pakistan), Kuldip Nayar witnessed at first hand the collapse of trust between Hindus and Muslims who were living together for generations, and like multitude of population he was forced to migrate to Delhi across the blood-stained plains of Punjab. From his perilous journey to a new country and to his first job as a young journalist in an Urdu daily, Nayar’s account is also the story of India. From his days as a young journalist in Anjam to heading India’s foremost news agency, UNI and from mainstream journalism to starting his now immensely popular syndicated column, ‘Between the Lines’, Nayar has always stood for the freedom of press and journalism of courage. Widely respected for his columns, his autobiography opens on the day Pakistan Resolution was passed in Lahore in 1940 and takes us on a journey through India’s story of a nation working on its foreign policy, development plans, relations with neighbouring countries, and dealing with coalition politics among others. From events of historical and political relevance like Tashkent Declaration and the 1971 war and the liberation of Bangladesh, to interviewing Zulfikar Ali Bhutto and Mujibur Rahman and from meeting Pakistan’s father of nuclear bomb, Dr A.Q. Khan, to his close association with Lal Bahadur Shastri and Jayaprakash Narayan, Nayar’s narrative is a detailed inside view of our nation’s past and present.
...more
Hardcover
,
464 pages
Published
July 2012
by Roli Books
(first published 1969)
The history of modern India (1930-2011) as witnessed by a Punjabi Hindu refuge from Sialkot(Pakistan) now based out of Delhi.
Mr Kuldeep Nayar's epic book is immensely readable due to the multitudes of anecdotes he shares of famous people (Nehru, Shastri, Indira, Vajpayee, Gujral, Ayub Khan, Bhutto, Muzib) all in first hand accounts.
The writer terms himself a left-of-center ideologist & a staunch secular, though after reading almost 500 pages of this book, he comes across as a true Punjabi-Pu
The history of modern India (1930-2011) as witnessed by a Punjabi Hindu refuge from Sialkot(Pakistan) now based out of Delhi.
Mr Kuldeep Nayar's epic book is immensely readable due to the multitudes of anecdotes he shares of famous people (Nehru, Shastri, Indira, Vajpayee, Gujral, Ayub Khan, Bhutto, Muzib) all in first hand accounts.
The writer terms himself a left-of-center ideologist & a staunch secular, though after reading almost 500 pages of this book, he comes across as a true Punjabi-Puttar, a sucker for unified Punjab. But that's very normal as numerous Tamils who seek a Tamil state encompassing Tamilnadu, SriLanka & Singapore. As does greater Bengal by many Bengali's both sides of the border.
As a nation-state India has been very young, so such thoughts of cultural yearnings are but natural.
His anti-Congress & anti-BJP rattle (as claimed in this book) did wean him of many privileges. But being close to both Shastri & Vajpayee he did manage to be in the limelight (He was part of the govt troop at Tashkant & the bus ride to Lahore in 1997)
His closeness to the Janta Dal earned him UK-ambassadorship & Rajya Sabha seat.
One thing I noticed of this book was it's Delhi centric coverage. South of India, East of India & West of India is just mentioned in pauses. The entire History of India as happened in & around Delhi takes the entire narrative!
Wish the author had written more about the other parts of India too!
...more
As a journalist nayar sahib has taken up political dimensions of his past which shaped the present institutions of the country , as a matter of fact that shaped lives of millions of people
This book is a must read for anyone who is curious about the factors that shaped India's political scenario from the time of independence to the present day. An exciting and informative book!
kukdip Nayar ,veteran journalist From India, who have witnessed the every subtle event since independance.
'Between the Lines' , name itself suggests the incidents, anecdots which were coverted in the folds of time are revealed by the author.
There are specially two chapters from the book which are congizable in my opinion.
First is about the Bilingualism (a famous debate about the Hindi whether it should be a 'National'? Language or Not). In this chapter ,author specially reports about the happen
kukdip Nayar ,veteran journalist From India, who have witnessed the every subtle event since independance.
'Between the Lines' , name itself suggests the incidents, anecdots which were coverted in the folds of time are revealed by the author.
There are specially two chapters from the book which are congizable in my opinion.
First is about the Bilingualism (a famous debate about the Hindi whether it should be a 'National'? Language or Not). In this chapter ,author specially reports about the happenings took place in the meetings of parliamentary committee, their conclusions ,Language Bill, pressure from north indians for imposer of Hindi as principal language all over the Nation.
If we are able to relate this events with current situation we will understand that the Hindi Was never our National language.
Second chapter is about the Notorious and humiliating defeat of our nation in Indo- Sino war of 1962. In this Chapter author has used his personal Diary's notes as a references to narrate the incidents from 7 September 1962 ( when china first time crossed the MacMohan Line) to 4 May 1963.
information mentioned through notes is first hand information and personal prejuidices are strictly avoided by author.
how Pandit Nehru was totally failed to understand the china's strategy, How our Intelligence failed to collect the data about the mustering of chinese army near border.( though CIA had informed new delhi about the approximate number of troops deployed by Chinese On Indian Border)
Other noteworthy facet of this chapter is author has mentioned the role of NAM , USA ,Uk, USSR, UAR, Pakistan, Cyleone,Burma, Nepal in post war diplomacy.
Nehru wrote to everyone personally asking for the help against china's intrusion in indian territory but literally no one was stand ( Except president of Egypt) with us agianst China.
Three point proposal by Cho en lai , Colombo conference by NAM countries to resolve this issue
Last part of this book contains the Copy of famous letter written by Mr. Vallabh bhai Patel to Jawaharlal Nehru in 1950, after the china's encroachment over Tibet.
In this letter patel had clearly exhibited his worries about the Incurion of China , Importance of Tibet as Buffer State and future threats from china.
...more
Not sure why the publishers have called this an autobiography - memoir would have been a better description. The parts relating to the Partition and the Nehru-Shastri-Indira era are interesting. The post-Indira part suffers from a lack of detail, perhaps indicating that the author may no more have been close to the center of power in New Delhi. The book is let down by too serious a tone. Nayar's writing is pedestrian. At times, one feels one's going through someone's personal diary. Still, with
Not sure why the publishers have called this an autobiography - memoir would have been a better description. The parts relating to the Partition and the Nehru-Shastri-Indira era are interesting. The post-Indira part suffers from a lack of detail, perhaps indicating that the author may no more have been close to the center of power in New Delhi. The book is let down by too serious a tone. Nayar's writing is pedestrian. At times, one feels one's going through someone's personal diary. Still, with all its faults, BTL serves the purpose of offering an inside perspective on some of the most tumultous years in Indian history.. that is, if the reader could look beyond the schoolboyish writing.
...more
Extremely well written. The part on the major migration that was witnessed during independence is quite overwhelming. Kuldip Nayar has brings in his years of experience as a top editor and journalist into good use. Having watched the political drama in very close quarters he comes out with many nuggets hitherto unknown. A very good resource for anyone interested in the history of India of the first thirty years post independence.
The book is brilliant, Very well written, gives you a virtual walk through of political developments in India from independence to present. There is no point throughout the book i felt bored. Though, after reading the book, i have a very pessimistic view on Indian politics and its foreign relations, Mr Nayar has put an extra effort to give the book an optimistic tint. And i do agree with him when he says "Optimism is a moral responsibility"
less of an autobiography and more of a story of the author's times, but i guess that should be expected to some extent, when someone has seen history getting made at such close-quarters and has hobnobbed with the who's who of politics, and all organs of the government...I was keen to pick up the book after having earlier read scoop by the same author
A good book which tells inside story of the working of Indian political system. Nayar has watched the system from close quarters and gives an indepth account of happenings after the independece. He throws light on the partition of India and Indo-China and Indo-Pak wars. A must read for all who have even slight interest in modern Indian history.
बहुत अचछा अनुभव था मैं पाकिसतान से हूँ आैर मुझे हिंदुसतान की सियासी तारीख के चंद पहलुआें काे करीब से जानने का माैका मिला।कहीं कहीं तारीख के मामले में खास कर पाकिसतान के साथ जुडी कुचछ ऐतिहासिक मामलाें में लेखक ने बहुत उजलत से अपना फैसला सादर किया है।लेखक ने बटवारे में जाे अनुभव किया था उतना नहीं लिखखा गया
बहुत अच्छा अनुभव था मैं पाकिस्तान से हूँ आैर मुझे हिंदुस्तान की सियासी तारीख़ के चंद पहलुआें काे क़रीब से जानने का माैक़ा मिला।कहीं कहीं तारीख़ के मामले में ख़ास कर पाकिस्तान के साथ जुड़ी कुच्छ ऐतिहासिक मामलाें में लेखक ने बहुत उजलत से अपना फ़ैसला सादर किया है।लेखक ने बटवारे में जाे अनुभव किया था उतना नहीं लिख्खा गया
...more
Author has penned down his experiences as his professional career advanced, with some of his insider experiences and his views - which u may or may not agree with. Overall a good read..
“Over the years I have felt that both the IAS and IPS have developed a kind of feudal class consciousness that does not go well with the service to the people that India needs. Their initial idealism begins to diminish within a few years of service and they gradually become part of the furniture.”
—
1 likes