Before Memory Fades by Fali S. Nariman is a revelatory, comprehensive and perceptive autobiography - candid, compelling and authoritative.Internationally admired and respected, Fali S. Nariman is a senior advocate of the Supreme Court of India. He began his career at the Bombay High Court in November 1950, and has since been active in the legal profession. Over the years,
Before Memory Fades by Fali S. Nariman is a revelatory, comprehensive and perceptive autobiography - candid, compelling and authoritative.Internationally admired and respected, Fali S. Nariman is a senior advocate of the Supreme Court of India. He began his career at the Bombay High Court in November 1950, and has since been active in the legal profession. Over the years, he has held several prestigious posts at both the national and international levels. He became a Member of Parliament (Rajya Sabha) in November 1999. He is the recipient of the Padma Bhushan (1991) and the Padma Vibhushan (2007).
Starting with his formative years, when he had the good fortune to interact with many
eminent judges and advocates, Fali S. Nariman moves on to deal with a wide variety of
important subjects, such as, the sanctity of the Indian Constitution and attempts to tamper with it. crucial cases that have made a decisive impact on the nation, especially on the
interpretation of the law, the relationship between the political class and the judiciary, the cancer of corruption and how to combat this menace, the author outlines measures to restore the now-low credibility of the legal profession, he also delineates his role in several high-profile cases. In recognition of his track record, the Government of India nominated him to the Rajya Sabha. He describes the highlights of his tenure there. Both members of the legal profession and the lay reader will find the contents informative and useful.
...more
Hardcover
,
first
,
372 pages
Published
June 15th 2010
by Hay House
(first published June 1st 2010)
Provides a good view of the legal history of India ever since it became free with some incisive observations about the state of the nation and its polity complementing the fund of insights about the legal process and anecdotes of noted lawyers and judges. The chapter on the Union Carbide case and the inter-state water disputes are though a little impenetrable...
This actually reads as a clear reflection of Mr. Nariman's personality. There are some interesting anecdotes, tips for young lawyers, policy prescriptions, lots of behind the scenes action - its like Mr. Nariman was holding forth and reminiscing to an audience hanging on his words.
To be honest the book could have done with better editing, sometimes its almost like notes which have been typed up, which should have been addressed. Its endearing as clearly being written by Mr. Nariman himself but
This actually reads as a clear reflection of Mr. Nariman's personality. There are some interesting anecdotes, tips for young lawyers, policy prescriptions, lots of behind the scenes action - its like Mr. Nariman was holding forth and reminiscing to an audience hanging on his words.
To be honest the book could have done with better editing, sometimes its almost like notes which have been typed up, which should have been addressed. Its endearing as clearly being written by Mr. Nariman himself but does detract from the quality of the book.
It was a personal shocker to know of his representation of Union Carbide and the part of the book dealing with this sounds faintly defensive too. The chapter on the Inter State Water Disputes could have been avoided entirely. The reflections on the Indian judiciary is exceptional.
Good reading for those interested in the legal profession in India. And inspiring!
...more
Very good book from an eminent citizen of India. Mr Nariman comes across as a humble, sincere and open person. The book gives insights into critical issues such as Parliamentary power to amend the Constitution, Executive Judicial relationships, inter state water dispute act, Judicial Governance and some great description of great Judges.. I also like the discussion on "Rule of law" Vs "rule by law". There other philosophical discussions therein.
Has very good coverage of Fali Nariman's professional career. The matter on the constitution, emergency and Bhopal gas tragedy are covered well and make for interesting reading. The book meanders into technical details more often than required. Would have been good if the book had more of Fali Nariman's personal life and interests.....
A most powerful Constitution lawyer in Indian history shares his experiences of Court and Justice system in India and his opinion about how it could be bettered. Moreover he discusses many important Constitution cases including some of which he has appeared. He also shares his experience in different countries and their law practices. I felt like reading some constitutional book with writers invaluable insight clubbed with humor and passion.A must read novel for every lawyer, law student or pers
A most powerful Constitution lawyer in Indian history shares his experiences of Court and Justice system in India and his opinion about how it could be bettered. Moreover he discusses many important Constitution cases including some of which he has appeared. He also shares his experience in different countries and their law practices. I felt like reading some constitutional book with writers invaluable insight clubbed with humor and passion.A must read novel for every lawyer, law student or persons who are interested in law.
...more
Nice book to read. Gives some insights about emergency period (1975) with author's own perspective. Author also makes his stand clear on the Bhopal Gas trgedy case. A must read for lawyers and wannabe lawyers.
Mr Nariman has mentioned a brief on his life and work in this book. He has also taken this opportunity to pen down his views on various famous / controversial judgements of his times and also reflected upon some of the deficiencies of our constitutions and how they can be remedied. Being an eminent lawyer, his views consists of lots of legal references at various places.
Written in a very simple and uncomplicated style, this book is definitely a worth read.
Nariman with his vast experience of the Indian judiciary shares his wisdom in this well written book. He critically analyses the strengths and weaknesses of the judicial system and ends the book with optimism.
I did not find the book interesting, may be because I like books in story telling manner , and this book seemed to only telling facts in bland manner. So I stopped reading the book after reading may be twenty odd pages.
A fascinating read. Witty, candid and interesting. Specifically liked the portions on the emergency, Bhopal gas tragedy and judges of the Supreme Court. Highly recommend this book.
Fali Sam Nariman is a distinguished Indian Constitutional jurist and senior advocate to the Supreme Court of India since 1971 and has remained the President of the Bar Association of India since 1991.Nariman is an internationally recognised authority on international arbitration. He is one of India's most distinguished constitutional lawyers and he has argued several leading cases.He remained Addi
Fali Sam Nariman is a distinguished Indian Constitutional jurist and senior advocate to the Supreme Court of India since 1971 and has remained the President of the Bar Association of India since 1991.Nariman is an internationally recognised authority on international arbitration. He is one of India's most distinguished constitutional lawyers and he has argued several leading cases.He remained Additional Solicitor General of India May 1972- June 1975.
He has been awarded the Padma Bhushan (1991), Padma Vibhushan (2007)and Gruber Prize for Justice (2002) and has remained nominated member of the Rajya Sabha, the Upper House of the Parliament of India for a term (1999–2005).Also honoured by NDTV among the 25 living Indian legends on December 14, 2013.
Born in 1929 in Rangoon to Sam Bariyamji Nariman and Banoo Nariman, Fali did his schooling from Bishop Cotton School, Shimla. Thereafter he studied B.A. (Hon.), in Economics and History from St. Xavier's College, Bombay (now Mumbai), followed by a Law degree (LL.B.) from the Government Law College, Mumbai in, 1950, after standing first in the Advocate's Examination and been awarded the Kinlock Forbes Gold Medal and Prize for Roman Law & Jurisprudence.His father initially wanted him to write the Indian Civil Service Examination. Since he could not afford it at that time, he chose law as his last option.
Nariman started his law practice at the Bombay High Court. After practicing for 22 years, he was appointed a Senior Advocate in the Supreme Court of India in 1971, a position he retains to date. He said that "My senior's senior, Jamsetjee Kanga was my mentor. He was like a father figure to me. He died at 93 and he is the one who, at the age of 92, told me that he was still learning. He had a tremendous memory and so does my son Rohinton. He was an Ordained Priest and so is Rohinton."[8]
Nariman was instrumental to the development of the Indian Constitution's Law. Nariman was Additional Solicitor General of India from May 1972 to 25 June 1975, resigning from that post upon the Declaration of Emergency on 26 June 1975.
Nariman argued in favour of Dow chemicals (the owned by Union carbide) in the infamous Bhopal gas disaster case, which he admitted as a mistake in recent times.He was instrumental in getting a deal between victims and the company outside court, which offered an amount of $470 million to the victims. He also argued in the famous case of the Supreme Court AoR Association, in which the Supreme Court took over the appointment of judges in the Higher Judiciary. He also appeared in many important cases like Golak Nath, S.P. Gupta, T.M.A. Pai Foundation, etc.
Nariman is the recipient of the Padma Vibhushan (in 2007) and Padma Bhushan (in 1991), respectively the second and third highest honors granted to civilians by the President of India. Both awards were for Nariman's contributions to jurisprudence and public affairs. Nariman was awarded the Gruber Prize for Justice in 2002.He dedicated his awards to his alma mater Bishop Cotton School in Shimla.
His books serves as an outstanding scholarly treatise on the Constitutional Law, its interpretation and application. His concern as a citizen of India laces all his writings and remains an inspiration for every student of Indian Law.
...more