I had a mixed experience reading this book. On the one hand, it carries a great deal of weight, purporting to be a first hand account of life in Spain during and just prior to the Spanish Civil War. However, the extremism of the author's partisan spirit leads to serious omissions - most notably the fact that the anti-communist Republican Andreu Nin may have been tortured and killed in her home - and an overly rosy depiction of compromised public figures, such as Doctor Negrín. The rhetoric is un
I had a mixed experience reading this book. On the one hand, it carries a great deal of weight, purporting to be a first hand account of life in Spain during and just prior to the Spanish Civil War. However, the extremism of the author's partisan spirit leads to serious omissions - most notably the fact that the anti-communist Republican Andreu Nin may have been tortured and killed in her home - and an overly rosy depiction of compromised public figures, such as Doctor Negrín. The rhetoric is understandable, given the many atrocities committed by Franco and his fascist allies, but it unfortunately clouds our view of what happened during that terrible time in Spain, in particular when referencing the complexities of the divisions and disagreements amongst the Republicans.
My own view of this book is further clouded by the strong likelihood that it was ghost written by someone other than the purported author and subject. If it is not, in fact, the autobiography that it purports to be, than the integrity of its content is seriously compromised. This is a shame, because much of the book has great potential value for its vivid and highly realistic descriptions of people and occurrences during the early twentieth century in Spain. That said, the writing style ranges from jargonistic to journalistic to novelistic, interspersed with lurid touches and moments of extreme pathos, much of it rendered in ponderous detail. Caveat lector.
...more
Of the 2 dozen or so books about the Spanish Civil War which I have read this ranks up there with Orwell's Homage to Catalonia. A first person account by a woman not favorably mentioned by some other writers (see Antonio Barea, The Forging of a Rebel, and Hotel Florida: truth, Love and Death in the Spanish Civil War by Amanda Vaill) or readers who found her writing to partisan. Life before the revolution in her aristocratic milleau and her curious eyes capture early 20th century Spain in a way t
Of the 2 dozen or so books about the Spanish Civil War which I have read this ranks up there with Orwell's Homage to Catalonia. A first person account by a woman not favorably mentioned by some other writers (see Antonio Barea, The Forging of a Rebel, and Hotel Florida: truth, Love and Death in the Spanish Civil War by Amanda Vaill) or readers who found her writing to partisan. Life before the revolution in her aristocratic milleau and her curious eyes capture early 20th century Spain in a way that even the best historical writers of the period like Paul Preston do not capture. Aristocrat goes Communist. Go for it girl! Loved it!
...more