Nationally syndicated columnist and prolific author Walter E. Williams recalls some of the highlights and turning points of his life. From his lower middle class beginnings in a mixed but predominantly black neighborhood in West Philadelphia to his department chair at George Mason University, Williams tells an "only in America" story of a life of achievement.
Hardcover
,
160 pages
Published
December 1st 2010
by Hoover Institution Press
(first published January 1st 2010)
You quickly understand that this book is witten by an economist and not a fine arts teacher. He becomes angry about teachers who make excuse for poorly written, bad grammar and mispelled words in work by black students. He indicated one black student who became angery that he gave an F for a paper in which a liberal professor had given an A and had written a lot of affirming remarks. Willaims says the answer is to give extra tutorial time to help the student and not to give grades that are unear
You quickly understand that this book is witten by an economist and not a fine arts teacher. He becomes angry about teachers who make excuse for poorly written, bad grammar and mispelled words in work by black students. He indicated one black student who became angery that he gave an F for a paper in which a liberal professor had given an A and had written a lot of affirming remarks. Willaims says the answer is to give extra tutorial time to help the student and not to give grades that are unearned. He talks of his own failure and the extra help he received that helped him be successful. He has no patiences with liberals. This sections makes the book priceless. "I occasionaly lose patience with some of my liberal colleagues.....he was spouting off guilt-motivated nonsense....I suggested he steal a car, get arrestted and get sentenced for a year or so at Philadelphia's Graterford Prison....by the time my 'brothers' got finished with him and had him wearing panties and makeup and carrying a pocketbook, he'd be happy about what his ancestors did to mine..... he hardly spoke to me again." "I Walter E. Willaims have benifitted greatly from the horrible suffering of my ancestors....my wealth and personal liberties are greater having been born in USA rather than any African country." He treats his wife of 48 years with loving respect. This is a book well worth your read.
...more
Books by men and women who started life with two strikes against them and managed to make something of themselves interest me and inspire me. Walter Williams' memoir fits well in that category.
From the book cover:
"From his lower-middle-class beginnings in a mixed but predominantly black neighborhood in West Philadelphia to his department chairmanship at George Mason University, the life of Walter E. Williams is an "only in America" story of achievement. In Up from the Projects, this nationally
Books by men and women who started life with two strikes against them and managed to make something of themselves interest me and inspire me. Walter Williams' memoir fits well in that category.
From the book cover:
"From his lower-middle-class beginnings in a mixed but predominantly black neighborhood in West Philadelphia to his department chairmanship at George Mason University, the life of Walter E. Williams is an "only in America" story of achievement. In Up from the Projects, this nationally syndicated columnist and prolific author recalls some of the highlights and turning points of his life."
He was raised by his mother with his father nowhere in evidence. At age 10 his small family moved to North Philadelphia's notorious Richard Allen housing projects (since demolished) where he was not a very dedicated student. He started college, but again, didn't particularly apply himself. A stint in the army shaped him up and he went back to school with much more focus when he got out of the military.
Williams earned his PhD at UCLA, and was at the time a self-described radical, much more in sympathy with Malcolm X than with Martin Luther King. But by the time he had finished his degree he had become a libertarian. He says now: "I learned that you have to evaluate the effects of public policy as opposed to intentions."
He has taught economics at George Mason University since 1980.
...more
Walter Williams begins his autobiography as one might expect, discussing his childhood. One that began in the "projects" in Philadelphia. What one does not expect and what sets the tone for his life and his story is his answer to the question he poses: "What was it like to grow up poor?" He immediately says, "we didn't consider ourselves poor; in fact, being called poor was an insult."(p 4) Thus he turns conventional thinking on its head and alerts the reader that his life and ideas will be unco
Walter Williams begins his autobiography as one might expect, discussing his childhood. One that began in the "projects" in Philadelphia. What one does not expect and what sets the tone for his life and his story is his answer to the question he poses: "What was it like to grow up poor?" He immediately says, "we didn't consider ourselves poor; in fact, being called poor was an insult."(p 4) Thus he turns conventional thinking on its head and alerts the reader that his life and ideas will be unconventional indeed, and sometimes inconvenient and somewhat radical.
He tells his story with simple and clear prose, demurring literary flourishes, providing straightforward reporting about his experiences in school, the army, searching for direction, and the importance of education and family.
I was most impressed that by sharing these experiences he demonstrated a life of integrity, courage, determination through hard work, intellect and curiosity, a sense of humor, and above all an independence in thought and action that, with a bit of luck led him to great achievement in his chosen field of economics. Some notable episodes included his defiance of racial stereotyping during an encounter with the academics of Amherst, his unconventional but principled criticisms of the "Davis Bacon Act" and other government actions, and his courageous decision to not join the Reagan administration. But these were no surprise following his example of independent thinking at UCLA that led him to question his professors including the famed Armen Alchian, and in doing so gaining their admiration for his courage and independent thought. He came into his own during the three decades of his tenure at George Mason University showing determination in developing private funding for the renowned Economics department and eventually leading it as the department head. Domestic episodes of his life include family scenes that demonstrated the importance of the women in his development: mother, wife and daughter.
I began reading this autobiography somewhat familiar with Williams' thought through his opinion columns and media appearances. My admiration for his defense of the liberty and the free market was increased by great measure learning of his development, not without some stumbles, into a principled leader who deserves the admiration of all who love liberty.
...more
Santa Claus left this book under my Christmas tree in 2010. It's a terrific lazy-day-in-pajamas read.
I admit I'm prejudiced in favor of Walter Williams. He's always saying things that make sense to me. I spent some of my growing up years in post World War II housing projects in Pennsylvania and later in Ohio, and Williams might have been describing my own experiences, except that back then neighborhoods were racially segregated. (I, by the way, lived in a two bedroom/one bathroom apartmentof may
Santa Claus left this book under my Christmas tree in 2010. It's a terrific lazy-day-in-pajamas read.
I admit I'm prejudiced in favor of Walter Williams. He's always saying things that make sense to me. I spent some of my growing up years in post World War II housing projects in Pennsylvania and later in Ohio, and Williams might have been describing my own experiences, except that back then neighborhoods were racially segregated. (I, by the way, lived in a two bedroom/one bathroom apartmentof maybe 900 square feet with my parents, my three siblings, and for a while my grandmother from Algeria.) I suspected American Black people and White people might experience life in similar ways due to our common human natures, language and culture, but until Black voices started telling their stories, it was impolite for White children of my generation to ask about their lives.
The always independent and amusing Dr. Williams' very short biography is fun to read and there were a few times I laughed aloud. It portrays the life of poor black Americans when families were still intact, and work was readily available for teenagers. Although he is a conservative economist of the Milton Friedman school (I am really simplifying here), he maintains his own unique take on a wide variety of subjects. Until he married, Mr Williams was in trouble with the law and with every sort of
The always independent and amusing Dr. Williams' very short biography is fun to read and there were a few times I laughed aloud. It portrays the life of poor black Americans when families were still intact, and work was readily available for teenagers. Although he is a conservative economist of the Milton Friedman school (I am really simplifying here), he maintains his own unique take on a wide variety of subjects. Until he married, Mr Williams was in trouble with the law and with every sort of authority figure imaginable, even to the point of a considered court martial. I seldom feel that a book should have been longer, but in this case, I do. My guess is that he is a private person and was not inclined to say more than he did.
...more
I sat down last night thinking I would just dabble in this book - and I ended up reading it in one sitting. It's short and sweet, and very interesting.
I love listening to Walter Williams on the radio, and this book gave me a fascinating look into his past, and what it was like to grow up as a black man in turbulent times.
I'd encourage my kids to read this, when they're older. They can learn a lot from this hardworking man.
Walter Williams and Thomas Sowell both grew up poor, even though they are middle-class now. So the criticism of some liberals that they know nothing about poverty is invalid. Walter Williams made it on his merits, so the criticism of some liberals that Williams is a hypocrite for criticizing affirmative action is invalid. Williams, in fact, tried to avoid being the beneficiary of affirmative action. It is demeaning to African Americans who have made it without the benefit of racial preferences t
Walter Williams and Thomas Sowell both grew up poor, even though they are middle-class now. So the criticism of some liberals that they know nothing about poverty is invalid. Walter Williams made it on his merits, so the criticism of some liberals that Williams is a hypocrite for criticizing affirmative action is invalid. Williams, in fact, tried to avoid being the beneficiary of affirmative action. It is demeaning to African Americans who have made it without the benefit of racial preferences to be told that they were not good enough to have gotten ahead without a thumb on the scale. It is also unfair to label as Uncle Toms those Black public intellectuals who favor capitalism over socialism. Lefties call them opportunists, who get ahead by kissing right-wing, white a--. But there are far more employment opportunities for those Black intellectuals who kiss the left cheek.
Some of Williams early work as an economists concerned the pernicious effects of minimum wage law, in particular, the 1931 Davis-Bacon Act. House of Representatives member Robert L. Bacon introduced the act in response to union complaints against the importation of cheap colored labor from the South to work at a veterans hospital construction project in Long Island, New York. The other sponsor, Senator James Davis, was an anti-immigrant racist.
Williams talks about growing up poor in the northeast, and later moving to California, where he studied economics. Repeated incidents show that this Williams fellow was quite a troublemaker when he was young, pulling pranks on his peers, pretending to be incompetent to avoid work, getting into trouble with the law, complaining about unjust treatment, and being a general, all-around nuisance. From what I hear, he hasn't changed.
...more
This is a quick read. It is not deep, but makes a few deep points.
The most significant point that I can recall most obviously is this: Williams says that it was very common for him and his friends to work at part time jobs growing up. This was especially important for young Black youths in his neighborhood (in Philadelphia). They worked not just for money, but employment also was an opportunity to build self-respect and self-efficacy. Those in his circle who were not good in school, from a lowe
This is a quick read. It is not deep, but makes a few deep points.
The most significant point that I can recall most obviously is this: Williams says that it was very common for him and his friends to work at part time jobs growing up. This was especially important for young Black youths in his neighborhood (in Philadelphia). They worked not just for money, but employment also was an opportunity to build self-respect and self-efficacy. Those in his circle who were not good in school, from a lower class background, and with a disrupted homelife--they could still work as young men, and feel good about themselves because of it.
( Yes, he blaims the minimum wage laws for higher youth unemployment currently. )
(Williams mostly was raised by a single mother, who apparently was relatively stern and demanded a lot of effort from him. He did not get a lot of opportunities to "coast" as a child. His school was at least moderately demanding--the pupils mostly Black, the teachers and administrators nearly all white.
If you are a quick reader you can read this in an evening. I would say that Thomas Sowell's memoir is deeper and more thoughtful. It seems Williams wrote this in part because the urging of his friends / family / colleagues. Hoover Institution thought it worth publishing.
Thomas Sowell in his memoir comes across as more thoughtful and with a bit of prickly, no-nonsense personality. Offhand I would say that Williams comes across as more boisterous, straightforward, and matter-of-fact. Quick to confront, not too quick to take offense, and quick to forgive slights real or imagined.
...more
This biography is brief, but I don't see that as being a drawback. Williams covers the main points of his life and worldview without delving into needless details. It's an inspiring message, well-delivered with just the right amount of anecdotes and self-deprecating humor.
Of course, Williams is an impassioned proponent for libertarian-leaning economics, and most readers will know this going in. I think it helps to be sympathetic to this worldview, but I believe even liberal readers will have to
This biography is brief, but I don't see that as being a drawback. Williams covers the main points of his life and worldview without delving into needless details. It's an inspiring message, well-delivered with just the right amount of anecdotes and self-deprecating humor.
Of course, Williams is an impassioned proponent for libertarian-leaning economics, and most readers will know this going in. I think it helps to be sympathetic to this worldview, but I believe even liberal readers will have to admire Williams for his intelligence, hard work, and refusal to tolerate lame excuses from anyone, most of all himself.
The reader will learn of Williams' early trouble-making and mistakes, and how those experiences eventually led him away from "thinking with his heart" to thinking with his head. He acknowldges that he had some luck and help along the way, and that's the beauty of it: just about all of us have some luck and help along the way. The trick is not to squander it, or as Willams says: when opportunity knocks you don't want to say wait while I pack. You want to be ready to go.
Willams is a talented wordsmith who treats us to a story of a life well-lived, with hard learned lessons and well deserved joy throughout. Good for him, and good for the reader who picks this book up.
...more
Himself a product of the projects, as the title indicates, Dr. Williams tells his story of how his race and class mattered to achieving what he has thus far.
Unlike today's rhetoric vouching for greater affirmative action and other interventionist programs from the government, Williams asserts that such programs have led to poorer performance in the communities they were applied to. For example, in his own neighborhood in Philadelphia, the students to
Dr. Williams is the anti-anti-establishment.
Himself a product of the projects, as the title indicates, Dr. Williams tells his story of how his race and class mattered to achieving what he has thus far.
Unlike today's rhetoric vouching for greater affirmative action and other interventionist programs from the government, Williams asserts that such programs have led to poorer performance in the communities they were applied to. For example, in his own neighborhood in Philadelphia, the students today graduate with only 4% of its class testing "proficient" in reading and writing. When Williams was the student at the high school, such numbers were unheard of. This example is only a snippet of a larger problem caused by an increasing demand for government leniency.
As Williams trekked towards his Ph.D and later on a career as a public intellectual, the hurdles along the way were of a different stripe than ones a reader might expect from an African-American growing up in the 60's. Instead of taking advantage of the affirmative action policies in universities demanding more "minority" professors, Williams rejected any offer made under such conditions. Relying only on a non-biased criteria of academic excellence, Williams wished to be considered as an economist, not a "black economist."
Williams, as he surveys his life-long journey in his seventies (when the book was written), offers advice on how the margins of society can improve to produce individuals such as himself. He argues that hard work and a negative view of government help will allow individuals from today's projects to become more independent and learn of ways to develop an enriching sense of citizenry that has been stripped away by the spoon-feeding policies of the government--policies that have produced the opposite of intended effects and have now served to keep the marginal in their place.
Williams is a towering figure today that offers clarity to the issues of race and economics in ways that few can match.
...more
Too short, and would have appreciated him expanding a bit on some of his ideas, but he seems to see an autobiography as a book that discusses life changes, defeats, and accomplishments, and not so much changes in philosophy and what drove those. I don't think Williams was ever the Marxist Thomas Sowell was, but I do get the impression that Williams changed his mind on a few things, however he never really examines this beyond recognizing some of the people who had an influence on him.
I picked this book up at the library because I like autobiographies. I had never heard of the author. He is an economist who leans toward libertarian ideology. He was a person with a strong personality. As a young person in the military, I think he had some annoying behaviors, but he eventually relaxed a bit. This book shows that through hard work, you can achieve a lot. However, it comes at a price for a black person who doesn't have the same philosophies as the majority of the people like hims
I picked this book up at the library because I like autobiographies. I had never heard of the author. He is an economist who leans toward libertarian ideology. He was a person with a strong personality. As a young person in the military, I think he had some annoying behaviors, but he eventually relaxed a bit. This book shows that through hard work, you can achieve a lot. However, it comes at a price for a black person who doesn't have the same philosophies as the majority of the people like himself. He definitely didn't want to ever be an affirmative action hire, he only wanted a job on his own merits. He was a professor first and foremost, but also a syndicated columnist, and involved in think tanks etc. He wasn't super popular, but he earned people's respect. Interesting book, but it could have had a lot more content than it did.
...more
I love Walter Williams and had the honor of meeting him briefly back in 2004. Maybe I expected too much, but I was underwhelmed by "Up from the Projects". It does have its moments when the Walter Williams I looked for reveals himself, but those are usually when he departs from storytelling and discusses ideas. His accomplishments are admirable, especially considering the obstacles presented his race in his younger years. If you wonder where he came from, this will give you some answers. If you w
I love Walter Williams and had the honor of meeting him briefly back in 2004. Maybe I expected too much, but I was underwhelmed by "Up from the Projects". It does have its moments when the Walter Williams I looked for reveals himself, but those are usually when he departs from storytelling and discusses ideas. His accomplishments are admirable, especially considering the obstacles presented his race in his younger years. If you wonder where he came from, this will give you some answers. If you want to know what he thinks and how he came to those conclusions, read something else.
...more
I always look forward to reading Walter Williams' columns in the paper or on the internet. Williams grew up with his single mom after his father deserted the family. Williams later received his PhD in economics and is currently on the faculty at George Mason University in Northern Virginia. He is a common sense conservative with some interesting ideas.
If you like this interview, you will like his book:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=...
If you don't like his interview, you should read his bo
I always look forward to reading Walter Williams' columns in the paper or on the internet. Williams grew up with his single mom after his father deserted the family. Williams later received his PhD in economics and is currently on the faculty at George Mason University in Northern Virginia. He is a common sense conservative with some interesting ideas.
If you like this interview, you will like his book:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=...
If you don't like his interview, you should read his book and open your mind!
...more
I bought this book thinking it was another, "Ben Carson" type biography. Half way through I chucked it in the trash. The author admits through out the book lying many many times to get out of situations. I don't care how successful you are by the world's standards. If you don't have integrity, you've got nothing. This man, Walter E. Williams does not have the admiral character qualities that Ben Carson has. Very disappointing.
Also, the frequent use of the 'f' word didn't help.
Loved it! Walter Williams is one of my favorite people. Wonderful story of his life and influences. Perfect book for kids:
1. important life lessons
2. planning one's career
3. staying true to one's principles
4. values gained by trying many, many different jobs in life.
I agree with Thomas Sowell's review: only bad part of the book is that it is too short.
Walter Williams' autobiography is a very short read. I finished it in three days. Williams writes well and he certainly has had many experiences worth sharing. His unique perspective on discrimination during the 50s and 60s are interesting. I'd recommend this book to anyone, especially someone who hasn't read a biography recently.
One of my favorite writer's autobiography is a straightforward, enlightening read. It is a short walk-through of his life with short side tracts to explain his development. Not exactly a page turner, but a nice book to fill in the story behind the man that so many read.
This is such a quick read, but packs so much punch. Dr. Williams writes simply and clearly, but with a sense of humor and a critical eye turned on American race relations, academia and the culture at large.
Born in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Dr. Walter E. Williams holds a B.A. in economics from California State University, Los Angeles, and M.A. and Ph.D. degrees in economics from UCLA. He also holds a Doctor of Humane Letters from Virginia Union University and Grove City College, Doctor of Laws from Washington and Jefferson College and Doctor Honoris Causa en Ciencias Sociales from Universidad Franc
Born in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Dr. Walter E. Williams holds a B.A. in economics from California State University, Los Angeles, and M.A. and Ph.D. degrees in economics from UCLA. He also holds a Doctor of Humane Letters from Virginia Union University and Grove City College, Doctor of Laws from Washington and Jefferson College and Doctor Honoris Causa en Ciencias Sociales from Universidad Francisco Marroquin, in Guatemala, where he is also Professor Honorario.
Dr. Williams has served on the faculty of George Mason University in Fairfax, Virginia, as John M. Olin Distinguished Professor of Economics, since 1980; from 1995 to 2001, he served as department chairman. He has also served on the faculties of Los Angeles City College, California State University Los Angeles, and Temple University in Philadelphia, and Grove City College, Grove City, Pa.
Dr. Williams is the author of over 150 publications which have appeared in scholarly journals such as Economic Inquiry, American Economic Review, Georgia Law Review, Journal of Labor Economics, Social Science Quarterly, and Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy and popular publications such as Newsweek, Ideas on Liberty, National Review, Reader's Digest, Cato Journal, and Policy Review. He has authored six books: America: A Minority Viewpoint, The State Against Blacks, which was later made into the PBS documentary "Good Intentions," All It Takes Is Guts, South Africa's War Against Capitalism, which was later revised for South African publication, Do the Right Thing: The People's Economist Speaks, and More Liberty Means Less Government.
He has made scores of radio and television appearances which include "Nightline," "Firing Line," "Face the Nation," Milton Friedman's "Free To Choose," "Crossfire," "MacNeil/Lehrer," "Wall Street Week" and was a regular commentator for "Nightly Business Report." He is also occasional substitute host for the "Rush Limbaugh" show. In addition Dr. Williams writes a nationally syndicated weekly column that is carried by approximately 140 newspapers and several web sites.
Dr. Williams serves on several boards of directors: Grove City College, Reason Foundation and Hoover Institution. He serves on numerous advisory boards including: Cato Institute, Landmark Legal Foundation, Institute of Economic Affairs, and Heritage Foundation.
Dr. Williams has received numerous fellowships and awards including: Foundation for Economic Education Adam Smith Award, Hoover Institution National Fellow, Ford Foundation Fellow, Valley Forge Freedoms Foundation George Washington Medal of Honor, Veterans of Foreign Wars U.S. News Media Award, Adam Smith Award, California State University Distinguished Alumnus Award, George Mason University Faculty Member of the Year, and Alpha Kappa Psi Award.
Dr. Williams has participated in numerous debates, conferences and lectures in the United States and abroad. He has frequently given expert testimony before Congressional committees on public policy issues ranging from labor policy to taxation and spending. He is a member of the Mont Pelerin Society, and the American Economic Association.
...more