This autobiography by Emily has been called "probably the finest... in a literary sense, ever written in Canada."
Completed just before Emily Carr died in 1945, Growing Pains tells the story of Carr’s life, beginning with her girlhood in pioneer Victoria and going on to her training as an artist in San Francisco, England and France. Also here is the frustration she felt at
This autobiography by Emily has been called "probably the finest... in a literary sense, ever written in Canada."
Completed just before Emily Carr died in 1945, Growing Pains tells the story of Carr’s life, beginning with her girlhood in pioneer Victoria and going on to her training as an artist in San Francisco, England and France. Also here is the frustration she felt at the rejection of her art by Canadians, of the years of despair when she stopped painting. She had to earn a living, and did so by running a small apartment-house, and her painful years of landladying and more joyful times raising dogs for sale, claimed all her time and energy. Then, towards the end of her life, came unexpected vindication and triumph when the Group of Seven accepted her as one of them. Throughout, the book is informed with Carr’s passionatate love of and connection with nature.
Carr is a natural storyteller whose writing is vivid and vital, informed by wit, nostalgic charm, an artist’s eye for description, a deep feeling for creatures and the foibles of humanity--all the things that made her previous books Klee Wyck and Book of Small so popular and critically acclaimed.
Five stars for a number of reasons: 1)The personal record of the struggles of an emerging artist. 2) An artist who can write too! 3)It made me reconsider my opinions about Carr's work. 4)Carr's devotion to Western Canada's woods and native peoples. (Don't think I've ever read any book quite so lavishly in love with Canada.) 5)The record of the correspondence between two respected artists. 6)Last, but my favorite of all - Carr wrote all her books in her 70's, after her doctor told her she needed
Five stars for a number of reasons: 1)The personal record of the struggles of an emerging artist. 2) An artist who can write too! 3)It made me reconsider my opinions about Carr's work. 4)Carr's devotion to Western Canada's woods and native peoples. (Don't think I've ever read any book quite so lavishly in love with Canada.) 5)The record of the correspondence between two respected artists. 6)Last, but my favorite of all - Carr wrote all her books in her 70's, after her doctor told her she needed to pull back on the painting - she had not written before, other than for her own personal pleasure. And her writing is wonderful, just wonderful. Loved all the descriptions of Vancouver and Victoria from before the first world war. Highly recommended to anyone interested in the development of an artist. (A large part of the book is devoted to the time Carr spent in England and France studying art.)
...more
I really appreciated finding out more about this fascinating woman as she described her life. She self describes her rule for writing as "get to the point and never use a big word when a small one will do". She writes in a way that is not lofty and for an autobiography she spends a great bit of time describing mundane things from her day to day life that really showed me the value of valuing the mundane. After all are not those the moments we speak of every day? I want to be more mindful of what
I really appreciated finding out more about this fascinating woman as she described her life. She self describes her rule for writing as "get to the point and never use a big word when a small one will do". She writes in a way that is not lofty and for an autobiography she spends a great bit of time describing mundane things from her day to day life that really showed me the value of valuing the mundane. After all are not those the moments we speak of every day? I want to be more mindful of what passes before me in this life. I also really appreciated the advanced thoughts that Emily possessed for her time. What an independent soul. I was honored to read her story.
...more
Emily Carr (1871-1945), born to a provincial, religiously conservative family in western Canada, became an artist through her unflagging devotion, despite penury, illness, and scorn. She was at once shy, frail, and fearless. She enjoyed late life recognition and rewards, then age and infirmity put an end to her forest treks to paint, and she wrote a few wonderful books. Here she describes drawing from a live model for the first time: "I had dreaded this moment....Her live beauty swallowed up eve
Emily Carr (1871-1945), born to a provincial, religiously conservative family in western Canada, became an artist through her unflagging devotion, despite penury, illness, and scorn. She was at once shy, frail, and fearless. She enjoyed late life recognition and rewards, then age and infirmity put an end to her forest treks to paint, and she wrote a few wonderful books. Here she describes drawing from a live model for the first time: "I had dreaded this moment....Her live beauty swallowed up every bit of my shyness. I had never been taught to think of our naked bodies as something beautiful, only as something indecent....Here was nothing but loveliness-- a glad, life-lit body, a woman proud of her profession, proud of her shapely self, regal, illuminated, high-poised above our clothed insignificance." Through the decades in her autobiography, she becomes more and more cantankerous and isolated. But that phrase, "our clothed insignificance," so well describes what the artist sees, why we can see it too thanks to her, and why we gladly indulge the artist's eccentricity. I am eager now to see her paintings, and to recommend this book often.
...more
Emily Carr (1871-1945) byla kanadská malířka, jejíž nebývale silné obrazy zachycují divokou přírodu kanadského západu, hluboké lesy (žádné pěkné krajinky, ale zdrcující přívaly zeleně a mohutných hor) a indiánské osady. Když jsem zjistila, že kromě toho se na stará kolena vrhla i na sepisování memoárů, nadšeně jsem se po knize začala shánět. Nebudu chodit okolo horké kaše a přiznám, že jsem od „nejlepší kanadské autobiografie“ čekala něco dost odlišného. Za prvé – NENÍ to životopis, je to jen je
Emily Carr (1871-1945) byla kanadská malířka, jejíž nebývale silné obrazy zachycují divokou přírodu kanadského západu, hluboké lesy (žádné pěkné krajinky, ale zdrcující přívaly zeleně a mohutných hor) a indiánské osady. Když jsem zjistila, že kromě toho se na stará kolena vrhla i na sepisování memoárů, nadšeně jsem se po knize začala shánět. Nebudu chodit okolo horké kaše a přiznám, že jsem od „nejlepší kanadské autobiografie“ čekala něco dost odlišného. Za prvé – NENÍ to životopis, je to jen jedna (a navíc až třetí) za vzpomínkových knížek autorky (což jsem zjistila až ke konci knihy, kde Emily popisuje, jak se ke psaní dostala, ohlasy na své dílo a svoje vlastní nejistoty a obavy z literárního selhání), takže veliká část Emilyina života a tvorby zde prostě není. „Growing Pains“ měla být patrně věnována malování (stejně jako ostatní knížky zas zachycují její dětství či zážitky z indiánských vesnic), ale dobré tři čtvrtiny knihy zabírají vlastně vzpomínky na její studia v San Francisku, Londýně a Paříži, kde sice velmi vtipně a zajímavě popisuje své spolužáky, profesory, život v daných městech a řadu společenských návštěv, ke kterým se musela uvolit, ale o samotném malířství se nedozvíme prakticky nic. Teprve v závěru vyprávění se Emily otevírá a přibližuje nám víc svůj vztah k umění. Velmi zajímavé byly svým způsobem všechny části, ale nejbližší mi byly právě ty závěrečné.
Čtení Emilyiných vzpomínek pro mě bylo jak jízda na horské dráze. Po předchozím suchém pedantství Eganova životopisu Edwarda Curtise byla lehkost, s níž Emily popisuje svá studia, téměř zjevením, ale postupem času jsem měla pocit, že stále více zabředá do možná úsměvných, ale z mého úhlu pohledu venkoncem irelevantních příhod. V této fázi četby jsem si zapsala: „vzpomínková kniha Emilly Carrové perlí jak šampaňské a podobně rychle člověku stoupne do hlavy, ale když vyšumí, přemýšlíte, o čem jste se vlastně dočetli něco podstatného. Už před polovinou jsem si říkala, že kdyby své vzpomínky sepsala podobně literárně nadaná třeba.. švadlena, mohl být konečný dojem stejný – vtipně zachycené výseky z autorčina života, řada pitoreskních postaviček, které se objevují a zase mizí a ... co dál?“ Jenomže po každém pádu následoval zase vzestup, kdy autorka nabrala druhý dech a já s ní, jen abych o pár kapitol dál zase upadala do pocitů mírného znudění. A zase nahoru. A dolů. Uznávám, že chyba může být spíš na straně mých velikých (a nenaplněných) očekávání. Až ke konci jsem lépe nahlédla, v jakém rozpoložení Emily své vzpomínky vlastně psala – stará, nemocná (její celoživotní boj s chatrným zdravím je výstižně zachycen už v názvu celé knihy), fyzicky neschopná malovat, a přestala jsem se snažit Emily narvat do krabičky „význačná malířka“ a nechala ji žít. Protože Emily Carr musela být naprosto úžasná a vyjímečná žena, která se vzepřela konvencím doby, do úpadu studovala nové způsoby, jak vůbec zobrazit něco tak živelného a rozlehlého, jako je kanadská divočina, na koni jezdila do opuštěných míst, aby zde sama v terénu malovala a nakonec pod vlivem naprostého nezájmu či přímo posměchu veřejnosti od malování na téměř dvě desítky let upustila. Vždy žila sama, živila se pronajímáním pokojů, hrnčířstvím, chovem bobtailů, a většinu svých těžkostí odbyla pouze pár větami. Neuvěřitelně šťastnou shodou náhod se Marius Berbeau, antropolog studující indiány severozápadu, dozvěděl o bílé ženě, která sem jezdívala malovat obrazy, a zmínil se o ní řediteli kanadské Národní galerie. Ten nelenil, Emily vyhledal, přemluvil k výstavě 50 (!) obrazů, odvezl ji na východ a seznámil se Skupinou sedmi. Budiž jim všem dík! :)
...more
This was an interesting read offering insight into Emily Carr's writings, life, and paintings, and interesting (and extremely personal) perspectives on what it was like for her to be a young art student at odds with her time and place. However, the writing is very uneven and oddly paced. If you are new to Carr, I would recommend starting with
Klee Wyck
, short memoirs in the form of vivid, poetically composed "sketches."
Hundreds and Thousands: The Journals of Emily Carr
is also very interesting,
This was an interesting read offering insight into Emily Carr's writings, life, and paintings, and interesting (and extremely personal) perspectives on what it was like for her to be a young art student at odds with her time and place. However, the writing is very uneven and oddly paced. If you are new to Carr, I would recommend starting with
Klee Wyck
, short memoirs in the form of vivid, poetically composed "sketches."
Hundreds and Thousands: The Journals of Emily Carr
is also very interesting, more informal writing, capturing her artistic process and thinking (transcriptions of her journals).
...more
So thoroughly enjoyed this book, I will be sure to read her others. I had no idea that Carr was a writer as well as an artist. I always enjoy reading about women coming of age and learning their art at the turn of the century. This was doubly enjoyable because she described what that looked like in Victoria, BC. The best paragraph was the last, comparing herself to the old goose that can't join the flock in their migratory flight, but will still add her honks to the parting crowd and then nibble
So thoroughly enjoyed this book, I will be sure to read her others. I had no idea that Carr was a writer as well as an artist. I always enjoy reading about women coming of age and learning their art at the turn of the century. This was doubly enjoyable because she described what that looked like in Victoria, BC. The best paragraph was the last, comparing herself to the old goose that can't join the flock in their migratory flight, but will still add her honks to the parting crowd and then nibble on seeds. This of course was a "carefully crafted" portrait of Carr. I'd like to now read a biography for an outside perspective. There's a new Emily Carr show at the AGO starting in April - perfect timing.
...more
Emily Carr was a well known Canadian artist and author, originally from Victoria, BC, Canada. Her book begins with her childhood and proceeds through her teenage and early twenties as she pursues her interest in art. As a young woman from that era,it took courage and determination to deviate from the commonly accepted norm. The book is also an account of her struggles to have her art accepted, not only by the public but also by her family. Of course, in later years her art was accepted by the Gr
Emily Carr was a well known Canadian artist and author, originally from Victoria, BC, Canada. Her book begins with her childhood and proceeds through her teenage and early twenties as she pursues her interest in art. As a young woman from that era,it took courage and determination to deviate from the commonly accepted norm. The book is also an account of her struggles to have her art accepted, not only by the public but also by her family. Of course, in later years her art was accepted by the Group of Seven. Her books which were written in the later part of her life were warmly received. This book was well written and I found the early part of her life very interesting .
...more
I chose Emily Carr to do my history project on, and we had to discover what our historical person was truly like, and what their personality was. I decided to read her autobiography to get a feel for what details really formed her identity. It was very interesting to read because I did a small research project on her in grade eight, but I didn't know the events that happened in her childhood and early teens. She has many accomplishments, but when I read this book I discovered the little things i
I chose Emily Carr to do my history project on, and we had to discover what our historical person was truly like, and what their personality was. I decided to read her autobiography to get a feel for what details really formed her identity. It was very interesting to read because I did a small research project on her in grade eight, but I didn't know the events that happened in her childhood and early teens. She has many accomplishments, but when I read this book I discovered the little things in her early life that were very significant. This helped me tremendously on my project because you never know what it true and what it false on the web. Here, I got the information from the one and only, Emily Carr. She is a brilliant writer, and as an artist myself, it was very inspiring to read about her life. She saw Canada in the most creative, and magnificent ways. I am very glad that I decided to read this, because even though I did it for an assignment, it allowed me to enjoy the task that much more.
...more
Emily Carr writes not only of her natural growth from a child but also of her growth creatively. I did not realize how much desire it takes to be an artist. One doesn't merely pick up a pencil or a brush and there one is! That is probably what my own experience in art school was about. An art teacher asked me how much I was willing to work at this. I replied by pursuing no further.
Art to Emily Carr however was an obsession and a lifelong pursuit. In the end, she captured the spirit of Western C
Emily Carr writes not only of her natural growth from a child but also of her growth creatively. I did not realize how much desire it takes to be an artist. One doesn't merely pick up a pencil or a brush and there one is! That is probably what my own experience in art school was about. An art teacher asked me how much I was willing to work at this. I replied by pursuing no further.
Art to Emily Carr however was an obsession and a lifelong pursuit. In the end, she captured the spirit of Western Canada within the woods she loved so much.
I wonder if I would've befriended this rebellious painter in life as I did by her writing.
"Why, I didn't know you went to art school in San Fancisco and England. Nor that you were a close friend and correspondent with Lawren Harris." I was entranced and a bit intimidated.
As an aside to my own readers, I would like to further comment that I am pleased to have my own pursuits and obsessions.By them, I am a truer friend to myself and to others like Emily.
One of the few books, I have read twice. Oct 28, 1988 when I had a 5 month old no less and five years later.
...more
My bff and sharer of great books found this little volume of Emily Carr's autobiography after we had both read The Forest Lover by Susan Vreeland. Carr’s story in her own word focuses on her early life in British Columbia with her stern father, her very proper Victorian mother and two sisters. Carr tells of her rebellious childhood where she draws pictures on her fingernails, petticoats and in the margins of all her school books. She is an embarrassment to her family who send her to foreign art
My bff and sharer of great books found this little volume of Emily Carr's autobiography after we had both read The Forest Lover by Susan Vreeland. Carr’s story in her own word focuses on her early life in British Columbia with her stern father, her very proper Victorian mother and two sisters. Carr tells of her rebellious childhood where she draws pictures on her fingernails, petticoats and in the margins of all her school books. She is an embarrassment to her family who send her to foreign art schools starting at the age of 16 when she was sent to San Francisco, London and Paris.
Carr wrote this book when she could no longer paint. I believe that if this book were being printed today, it would fall into the category of memoir. Each of the fifty –five vignettes is perfectly shaped into stories that could stand alone. My very Favorite which truly shows what life was like for young Emily is titled Difference between Nude and Naked!
...more
The reason I picked up this book from the local library is because her name is mentioned everywhere around Vancouver, BC, Canada. I have also seen her works in the Vancouver Art Gallery and I just didn't "get" her art. In order to really find out why Emily Carr was a big deal I went straight to the source-her own words. I have only read a handful of biographies but none that have been written like you are reading a fiction book. Her descriptions of events enables you to step into her life and wi
The reason I picked up this book from the local library is because her name is mentioned everywhere around Vancouver, BC, Canada. I have also seen her works in the Vancouver Art Gallery and I just didn't "get" her art. In order to really find out why Emily Carr was a big deal I went straight to the source-her own words. I have only read a handful of biographies but none that have been written like you are reading a fiction book. Her descriptions of events enables you to step into her life and witness it in all of its details. This book is also part history on what it was like to grow up a female in 18th century Victoria. The book comprises of short stories of important moments in her life, mostly of her youth. A good read into the life of someone who struggled artistically, with her family and society. After reading her autobiography I now have an understanding and a new appreciate for her art.
...more
Emily Carr's
Growing Pains
is my favorite artist biography to date. The book is written in a way that makes you feel like Emily is confiding in you; hearing of small victories and bitter setbacks on her journey as a Canadian artist. You will fall in love with her personality, her brood of pets, and her infatuation with Canada's beauty. This book should be required reading for any student of Canadian Art.
This autobiography will give you a deep appreciation and respect for Carr's devotion to her
Emily Carr's
Growing Pains
is my favorite artist biography to date. The book is written in a way that makes you feel like Emily is confiding in you; hearing of small victories and bitter setbacks on her journey as a Canadian artist. You will fall in love with her personality, her brood of pets, and her infatuation with Canada's beauty. This book should be required reading for any student of Canadian Art.
This autobiography will give you a deep appreciation and respect for Carr's devotion to her medium. You will gain an intuition for the different phases of her life, and how each phase influenced her work.
By no means is this book just for artists or those who know Emily's work. When I picked it up, I knew almost nothing of this girl from Victoria with so much talent and determination. I will recommend this book highly, and often.
...more
What a beautiful book this is. Emily Carr had an interesting life and she sets it on the page in a way that is both charming and engaging, and that also gives you a very real sense of her character. I really enjoyed reading this, and am looking forward to reading more of her work, as well as looking at her amazing paintings.
Schitterende levensbeschrijving van Emily Carr, haar kracht en enthousiasme spatten van iedere bladzij, wat een strijd heeft die vrouw geleverd en wat is ze trouw gebleven aan haar kunst.
growing up on the westcoast, i was so sick of hearing about emily carr and seeing her sweeping, melancholic landscapes. i thought i already knew her life story, but after reading her autobiography, i realized that she really loved our rainforests and respected and revered first nation art work.
i think i've become a born-again emily carr fan. her writing style is much like her painting, simple yet dramatic. she is very personable and wasn't afraid to talk about herself in a modest and almost self
growing up on the westcoast, i was so sick of hearing about emily carr and seeing her sweeping, melancholic landscapes. i thought i already knew her life story, but after reading her autobiography, i realized that she really loved our rainforests and respected and revered first nation art work.
i think i've become a born-again emily carr fan. her writing style is much like her painting, simple yet dramatic. she is very personable and wasn't afraid to talk about herself in a modest and almost self-deprecating way.
an inspiring story for all artists of any medium.
...more
Actually I only read half of this book. I had really enjoyed a biography of Emily Carr, and love her paintings, so decided to give this autobiography a try. It felt a bit too painful and even tedious to me. I am sorry that Emily Carr was born too soon for the world, as she didn't fit into the social scene or even the art scene wherever she went. I think if she were a young artist today, she would be much happier. Fortunately we have her incredible paintings to appreciate in the museums of Victor
Actually I only read half of this book. I had really enjoyed a biography of Emily Carr, and love her paintings, so decided to give this autobiography a try. It felt a bit too painful and even tedious to me. I am sorry that Emily Carr was born too soon for the world, as she didn't fit into the social scene or even the art scene wherever she went. I think if she were a young artist today, she would be much happier. Fortunately we have her incredible paintings to appreciate in the museums of Victoria and Vancouver.
...more
Pulsing with unshakeable devotion to British Colombia, Carr paints an intimate portrait of her highs & lows, her travels abroad, and artistic insecurities as she grows and develops into one of Canada's most prized painters and writers. The autobiography reveals a fascinating time in the history of North America and its art scene. Carr shows us the artist's psyche in bold beautiful language that craves the fuel provided only by human (and animal) reassurance and understanding.
Emily Carr was born in 1871. She wrote this in the 1940's.
She traveled all over the world, mostly alone.
That is a worthy enough reason to read this woman's
artistic journey and her rebellious struggle to be an artist
and to be the woman that she wanted to be.
Emily Carr gave Canada and the world what Frida Kahlo for Mexico and the world
and Georgia O'Keeffe did for America and the world.
After reading Forest Lover, I was interested in hearing from Emily Carr about her life. She tells it like it is with no embellishments or apologies. Very refreshing and a good insight into her life, with not as much emphasis on her art as her other works.
I'm not a huge fan of Emily Carr's artwork itself, but this autobiography really sucked me in. Carr's independent spirit, dedication to her work, and eventual success as described in this book were quite inspiring.
Emily Carr writes in an engaging style and speaks very warmly of the Canadian wilderness. It is interesting to discover the woman behind the bold works of art that I have enjoyed.
It's hard to describe this book, it's such a breath of fresh air. It's written just like she is speaking to you in her funny way. It's a true window into her life which I loved.
Emily Carr (December 13, 1871 – March 2, 1945) was a Canadian artist and writer heavily inspired by the indigenous peoples of the Pacific Northwest Coast. One of the first painters in Canada to adopt a post-impressionist painting style, Carr did not receive widespread recognition for her work until later in her life. As she matured, the subject matter of her painting shifted from aboriginal themes
Emily Carr (December 13, 1871 – March 2, 1945) was a Canadian artist and writer heavily inspired by the indigenous peoples of the Pacific Northwest Coast. One of the first painters in Canada to adopt a post-impressionist painting style, Carr did not receive widespread recognition for her work until later in her life. As she matured, the subject matter of her painting shifted from aboriginal themes to landscapes, and, in particular, forest scenes. As a writer, Carr was one of the earliest chroniclers of life in British Columbia. The Canadian Encyclopedia describes her as a "Canadian icon".
...more
...more
Mar 13, 2012 04:42AM
L Harris. You two are opening my eyes, thanks.
:O)
Mar 13, 2012 05:51AM