"
This is what matters to me: the story of the scholarship boy who returns home one summer from college to discover bewildering silence, facing his parents. This is my story. An American Story
."
Hunger of Memory
is the story of Mexican-American Richard Rodriguez, who begins his schooling in Sacramento, California knowing just 50 words of English, and concludes his university
"
This is what matters to me: the story of the scholarship boy who returns home one summer from college to discover bewildering silence, facing his parents. This is my story. An American Story
."
Hunger of Memory
is the story of Mexican-American Richard Rodriguez, who begins his schooling in Sacramento, California knowing just 50 words of English, and concludes his university studies in the stately quiet of the reading room of the British Museum.
Here is the poignant journey of a "minority student" who pays the cost of his social assimilation and academic success with a painful alienation -- from his past, his parents, his culture -- and so describes the high price of "making it" in middle-class America. Provocative in its positions on affirmative action and bilingual education,
Hunger of Memory
is a powerful political statement, a profound study of the importance of language... and a moving, intimate portrait of a boy struggling to become a man.
"Arresting... Splendidly written intellectual autobiography."
THE BOSTON GLOBE
"Superb autobiographical essay... Mr. Rodriguez offers himself as an example of the long labor of change: its costs, about which he is movingly frank, its loneliness, but also its triumph."
THE NEW YORK TIMES BOOK REVIEW
...more
Paperback
,
Bantam edition
,
199 pages
Published
February 1983
by Bantam Books
(first published 1981)
Ok. So I did not enjoy this book, not because it was a terrible book, but because it angered me. I am Americanized and I try my very best to learn as much about my culture as possible. I want to embrace my culture and the fact that there is someone out there who wants to throw theirs away (when they know how to speak their language fluently and know their culture by nature) angers me. Maybe, then, it is a really good book because it got a response from me, because it impacted me, but I still can
Ok. So I did not enjoy this book, not because it was a terrible book, but because it angered me. I am Americanized and I try my very best to learn as much about my culture as possible. I want to embrace my culture and the fact that there is someone out there who wants to throw theirs away (when they know how to speak their language fluently and know their culture by nature) angers me. Maybe, then, it is a really good book because it got a response from me, because it impacted me, but I still can't help but get angry when I hear the author's name.
...more
I have taught Rodriguez's essay, "The Third Man" for four semesters at Columbia. Now I am in a class where this book was assigned to me. I mention this because this is a book about the learning process, its prizes and perils.
I can't stop thinking about this book, talking about it. Rodriguez fights for every sentence, every word. You can almost see the 200 revisions that have gone into each phrase, but not quite. This is a beautiful book that accomplishes what I thought to be an impossible task:
I have taught Rodriguez's essay, "The Third Man" for four semesters at Columbia. Now I am in a class where this book was assigned to me. I mention this because this is a book about the learning process, its prizes and perils.
I can't stop thinking about this book, talking about it. Rodriguez fights for every sentence, every word. You can almost see the 200 revisions that have gone into each phrase, but not quite. This is a beautiful book that accomplishes what I thought to be an impossible task: the autobiographical political manifesto. How many old men out there want to write memoirs cum polemics? All of them, I think. Rodriguez is young in this book, but he took a long time writing it (years).
My favorite idea in this book is RR's assertion that a great education can only be obtained with great sacrifice. By this, he doesn't mean hard work, he means that any time someone from a disadvantaged background obtains a great education, they sacrifice closeness with their family, their community. The price of the education is isolation, even loneliness.
For anyone who is trying to write a book for those who don't read books, for those who can't read, this book is your friend.
...more
This is a book some will love and others will hate.
I first read this book for a college course and found Mr. Rodriguez a bit of a complainer. I just finished re-reading and discovered I greatly enjoyed his writing style and was better able to understand his experience growing up Mexican-American in California. I am still a bit ambivilant It is, at times, a riviting personal narrative. about the interaction between language, culture and assimilation. Mr. Rodriguez poignantly communicates his sadn
This is a book some will love and others will hate.
I first read this book for a college course and found Mr. Rodriguez a bit of a complainer. I just finished re-reading and discovered I greatly enjoyed his writing style and was better able to understand his experience growing up Mexican-American in California. I am still a bit ambivilant It is, at times, a riviting personal narrative. about the interaction between language, culture and assimilation. Mr. Rodriguez poignantly communicates his sadness about his inability speak his native language with his dying grandmother or his parents. He takes a stand on issues of education that may go against what is expected of a Mexican-American, nor is he apologetic on his stand. In his later book of essays, wirtten almost a decade later, "Days of Obligation" his view of total assimilation is somewhat broken.
I read this book over Christmas break and it ruined my holiday! It's the memoirs of a lost man who seeks to justify the distance he feels from his family through his transformation by assimilation into a well to do American author. He sees the loss he has experienced as worth the price. The edition I have is recommended by conservative George Will need I say more to my liberal friends as to why I can not stand this book?
I will say more. It haunts me. I see him as the child I knew who wanted to b
I read this book over Christmas break and it ruined my holiday! It's the memoirs of a lost man who seeks to justify the distance he feels from his family through his transformation by assimilation into a well to do American author. He sees the loss he has experienced as worth the price. The edition I have is recommended by conservative George Will need I say more to my liberal friends as to why I can not stand this book?
I will say more. It haunts me. I see him as the child I knew who wanted to be white. He saw his ethnicity as a disadvantage (rightly so). Rodriquez makes the childhood mistake of equating educated with being white. He and his family agree by the urging of the nuns who educated him to lose his Spanish. Speak only English at home.
He is a lonely soul who I pity. The price of his success was too great and utterly unnecessary. His story only stokes my anger against the bigoted who yell speak English to the immigrant, who fear the changing demographics of America and who are hurting our immigrant students in US schools when we do not encourage them to keep their language but only push English on them. These fools think losing a language makes a person better. With Rodriguez I rest my case that it does not.
...more
“There are things so personal they can only be revealed to strangers.” For years I had condemned this book to the ‘conservative’ wing of American essays, but finally reading it, I’m pleasantly surprised. Decades ago Rodriguez a “comic victim of two cultures” gained some notoriety for opposing bilingual ed and affirmative action when to suggest so was heresy among liberals. Fine, but these essays are intriguing, intelligent and somber, unlike today’s mean-spirited and mindless right. This is a st
“There are things so personal they can only be revealed to strangers.” For years I had condemned this book to the ‘conservative’ wing of American essays, but finally reading it, I’m pleasantly surprised. Decades ago Rodriguez a “comic victim of two cultures” gained some notoriety for opposing bilingual ed and affirmative action when to suggest so was heresy among liberals. Fine, but these essays are intriguing, intelligent and somber, unlike today’s mean-spirited and mindless right. This is a story of a Mexican-American child who excels at reading, writing and, by his adulthood, alienating his simple parents. This is the author coming to be a public individual (English), so much so that he violates both his parents’ privacy (Spanish) and the collective needs of immigrants—i.e. heritage and Affirmative Action, but does so for interesting reasons that are worth disagreeing with. “Credo” is an excellent, assignable sketch of the different cultures of American Catholicism in the early 60s.
...more
Unlike Richard Rodriguez I'm not a Mexican-American, but I did grow up in a Spanish-speaking household since my mother is Puerto Rican. Of all the books about and by Hispanics I've read before or since, this is the one I most identified with, that really resonated and spoke to me. I could see much about my family reflected in his--attitudes towards education, skin color, religion... This book indeed was assigned reading in a Sociology class, because it does fit into that discipline. But it's als
Unlike Richard Rodriguez I'm not a Mexican-American, but I did grow up in a Spanish-speaking household since my mother is Puerto Rican. Of all the books about and by Hispanics I've read before or since, this is the one I most identified with, that really resonated and spoke to me. I could see much about my family reflected in his--attitudes towards education, skin color, religion... This book indeed was assigned reading in a Sociology class, because it does fit into that discipline. But it's also known for Rodriguez' positions within it on Affirmative Action and Bilingual Education--which I agreed with--particularly after reading this. He talks about what he lost with the intimacy built by speaking Spanish, yes--but that to function in America what he needed was a
public
language--which in this country means English first and foremost. And that to gain that public voice and move into the mainstream of American society such a sacrifice is crucial and necessary. It's also a moving, powerful, and beautifully written biography.
...more
Rodriguez is often vilified by academic leftists for his conservative views on bilingual education (against it) and affirmative action (against it). Strangest of all, he wants to go back to the Latin mass. He is a gay, Mexican-American Catholic who got his PhD in Renaissance Literature and then dropped out of the academic circuit because he felt Ivy League schools were courting him due to his ethnicity. Now he makes a living off his books, articles, and boyfriend.
This is more a story of his ear
Rodriguez is often vilified by academic leftists for his conservative views on bilingual education (against it) and affirmative action (against it). Strangest of all, he wants to go back to the Latin mass. He is a gay, Mexican-American Catholic who got his PhD in Renaissance Literature and then dropped out of the academic circuit because he felt Ivy League schools were courting him due to his ethnicity. Now he makes a living off his books, articles, and boyfriend.
This is more a story of his early years and the mental negotiations of being "a scholarship boy." --Which he continually refers to in ponderous parentheses. Well, being an 8-year scholarship girl, I feel I have to say he is a little bit right and a little bit making excuses for his own conservatism and trying to trace it to a larger dynamic.
His writing is very reserved and serious, making his prose succinct but ultimately a bit dull. Also, in light of today's tell-all memoir culture, it is funny/quaint how he thinks he is doing something huge by revealing his mildly awkward childhood memories about being a child genius with assimilation anxiety. The genre has gotten into much deeper waters in the past 30 years!
I happen to read this between "Vows" and "Fun House" and I was struck by how both those books really put it all out there in a much more engaging way. The best thing I took away from the book was his argument that by design education changes people and we cannot pretend to be the old person we were once we have committed fully to the process of schooling.
...more
Many of the essays in this collection are wonderful. I can relate to his feelings about being a child of immigrant Mexican parents and one of my favorite essays is the one about his complexion. It's when Rodriguez goes beyond the personal that he sometimes loses me. Many times his essays are abstract intellectual reflections that are obtuse enough for me to not care. Still, even some of those have nuggets of thought I find interesting and the most controversial are his feelings on bilingual educ
Many of the essays in this collection are wonderful. I can relate to his feelings about being a child of immigrant Mexican parents and one of my favorite essays is the one about his complexion. It's when Rodriguez goes beyond the personal that he sometimes loses me. Many times his essays are abstract intellectual reflections that are obtuse enough for me to not care. Still, even some of those have nuggets of thought I find interesting and the most controversial are his feelings on bilingual education and affirmative action. It is reassuring to find myself in similar company, that labels are more exclusionary than the opposite. Rodriguez's books is most enjoyable though as a personal account of what it was like to grow up as the only Mexican-American on the block.
I keep going back and forth on whether I like this book more or not. In the end, I think it is an important book to read on a historical level and since there are not many books by Mexican-Americans on this subject, a rare insight into the Mexican-American middle class experience. It's easy to find the ex-homeboy accounts, which I also think are important, but not everyone of color grows up in the ghetto.
...more
Hunger of Memory is about a Mexican American named Richard Rodriguez who goes to Sacremento to go to school. Not knowing much English he still wants to survive this new way of life and become something of himself. His family, his past, and his culture didn't support his dream of becoming a success. This story explains that Richard had to loose something in order to gain something, it explains how important a language is, how little things of a culture is important in a person. When you come into
Hunger of Memory is about a Mexican American named Richard Rodriguez who goes to Sacremento to go to school. Not knowing much English he still wants to survive this new way of life and become something of himself. His family, his past, and his culture didn't support his dream of becoming a success. This story explains that Richard had to loose something in order to gain something, it explains how important a language is, how little things of a culture is important in a person. When you come into a different environment that has a different language and tradition rather than what you are you feel awkward, just like a stranger and you try to act like you are one of them, but when your back home you feel better because you dont have to pretend in front of people that you're something else. That's exactly what I go through when I go to India. Just because I wasn't born in India, doesn't mean I'm not Indian. When I try to speak Indian people laugh, but I understand the language fully. When I walk on the streets people stare at me as if I'm some tourist. That is what Richard feels like in school and in that sort of environment and he has feelings of regrets.
...more
Richard Rodriguez is stellar at making you internalize the pathos that he pretty much writes in blood on the pages of his book.
While the subject matter was interesting to me (Latino man finding his place in a country that does not accept him as he is), I could not relate much to flavor in which these sentiments were delivered.
Rodriguez's personality is one that had to fight his way through his journey of change. This very bittersweet uphill struggle is believable and not out of order at all.
I j
Richard Rodriguez is stellar at making you internalize the pathos that he pretty much writes in blood on the pages of his book.
While the subject matter was interesting to me (Latino man finding his place in a country that does not accept him as he is), I could not relate much to flavor in which these sentiments were delivered.
Rodriguez's personality is one that had to fight his way through his journey of change. This very bittersweet uphill struggle is believable and not out of order at all.
I just don't personally need all that drama to make it from point A to point B, so I can't entirely understand someone who parades their need to do so all around the neatly-typed paragraphs of their story.
Admittedly, if it wasn't for people like Rodriguez fighting the good fight, I may not be here in quite the same position I am today. Thank you fighters. It's just I prefer realized inspiration over guilted admiration.
I liked this book, ok. I mean I liked it because it was well-written but overall, it was just ok. I thought at first he was devling into the transformation of immigrants until I was able to discuss this book with people of his ethnic background. They were angry with him. I was curious to find out why.
It did change my view of the book but not by much. It still was a well written memoir. He still sounds like a douchebag when reflecting back on his family and the cultural stigmas he has had to fac
I liked this book, ok. I mean I liked it because it was well-written but overall, it was just ok. I thought at first he was devling into the transformation of immigrants until I was able to discuss this book with people of his ethnic background. They were angry with him. I was curious to find out why.
It did change my view of the book but not by much. It still was a well written memoir. He still sounds like a douchebag when reflecting back on his family and the cultural stigmas he has had to face throughout his career.
I hope one day someone might write a rebuttal memoir to this memoir so I can read about the life of someone who didn't grow up to be someone with his head stuck up his ass trying to find the meaning of life through color.
...more
When I decided to pick this book to read I was in my early 20's. The first chapters I felt I could somehow relate to the struggle in trying to assimilate to the mainstream culture. However, as I continue reading I was disappointed when I read further. I got the feeling that he was ashamed of his roots and felt that he was someone who is phony and he was not able to fit in with his family because of the education he had attain at UCLA. I am Mexican American and also attended college. When I was a
When I decided to pick this book to read I was in my early 20's. The first chapters I felt I could somehow relate to the struggle in trying to assimilate to the mainstream culture. However, as I continue reading I was disappointed when I read further. I got the feeling that he was ashamed of his roots and felt that he was someone who is phony and he was not able to fit in with his family because of the education he had attain at UCLA. I am Mexican American and also attended college. When I was a student I never felt I had to assimilate to the mainstream culture and forget from where I came from. I am proud to be bi-cultural and do not have to pretend to be someone I am not. My family have taught me well.
...more
Richard Rodriguez's Hunger of Memory is about the certain benefits and inevitable costs of getting higher education and the solitary life of a writer. His self-portraiture applies a rather austere and bleak and spartan writing style and voice and evokes an autobiographical speaker's convinced and convicted sense of melancholy, loss, loneliness, and lamentation. As a reader, I was kept away from getting too close for comfort and thus remained at an emotional and intellectual distance. Of course,
Richard Rodriguez's Hunger of Memory is about the certain benefits and inevitable costs of getting higher education and the solitary life of a writer. His self-portraiture applies a rather austere and bleak and spartan writing style and voice and evokes an autobiographical speaker's convinced and convicted sense of melancholy, loss, loneliness, and lamentation. As a reader, I was kept away from getting too close for comfort and thus remained at an emotional and intellectual distance. Of course, it could just be me. It could be me. Hunger and Memory, be mine.
...more
Hunger of Memory is the personal account of Richard Rodriguez's troubles of being a bilingual student growing up in America. He questions the teaching approach that is used with bilingual students, as he believes that bilingual students should be educated with the public language, as not focusing enough on the public, in his situation English, and his first known language, Spanish, does not prepare him, as well as others, for the public world and does not give the bilingual student a fair chance
Hunger of Memory is the personal account of Richard Rodriguez's troubles of being a bilingual student growing up in America. He questions the teaching approach that is used with bilingual students, as he believes that bilingual students should be educated with the public language, as not focusing enough on the public, in his situation English, and his first known language, Spanish, does not prepare him, as well as others, for the public world and does not give the bilingual student a fair chance. He also explains how his education made him lose a connection to his family and culture. His parents supported him though, as they wanted him to be accustomed to American society. He would surpass all blockades, eventually earning his way to a Ph.D in English Renaissance Literature. Another topic Richard Rodriguez addresses is the Roman Catholic Church and its style of teaching. Comparing what he was taught before his Roman Catholicism days, he regrets losing what he had previously learned, but accepts reality. He also criticizes american affirmative action policies, as he believed he was offered certain jobs and positions only due to the fact that he was an educated Latino. I found this novel not very interesting, as I have not been in his shoes. I believe this novel is one more intended for persons who have gone through the troubles of Richard Rodriguez, for which I have not. I found many individual facts and scenes to create a spark of interest, but overall this book was not for me.
...more
This book was pretty infuriating to read. Rodriguez contradicts himself over and over again and many of his statements are very hypocritical. He argues that elementary education needs reform, yet he knows nothing of the public school system in which the majority of minorities go through in this country. In my opinion, he is completely out of touch with the subject matter he discusses and therefore it makes it hard for me to see any merit in his stances.
What did you think? Goodreads asks. Indeed this book gave me a lot to think about. Although it was written over 30 years ago, he brought up some points that are still in contention. As in many nonfiction books, Mr. Rodriguez has the tendency to re-state his case repeatedly in various permutations.
The main points that I distilled from it are that Affirmative Action is bad because it tends to give people who aren't really disadvantaged unnecessary advantage. He seems to forget that prior to affir
What did you think? Goodreads asks. Indeed this book gave me a lot to think about. Although it was written over 30 years ago, he brought up some points that are still in contention. As in many nonfiction books, Mr. Rodriguez has the tendency to re-state his case repeatedly in various permutations.
The main points that I distilled from it are that Affirmative Action is bad because it tends to give people who aren't really disadvantaged unnecessary advantage. He seems to forget that prior to affirmative action, during times of quotas, the quota for many minority groups was 0. It was irrelevant if the person applying was economically disadvantaged or not. That said, Rodriguez makes a good point when he says that more attention should be paid to economic disadvantage and to improving the elementary and high schools in poor neighborhoods so that students from such schools will be capable of going to college.
As in many programs, a good concept can be unsuccessful if inadequately funded. Rodriguez confuses the concept of Affirmative Action with the way such programs were carried out on a lot of college campuses. Coming to college with inadequate foundations, he saw many such students fail for lack of enough academic support. He has a point that that should have been provided.
Throughout the book, Rodriguez seems to be conflicted about his identity as a Mexican from a working-class family. Although all his siblings were academically and financially successful, none of them seemed to share his pain about moving up in the class struggle and thus, farther away from their working class parents. Indeed, at the time that he wrote this book,Rodriguez seems to be struggling with many personal issues. That was over 30 years ago. I hope that he's resolved them by now. At any rate, it was an interesting read.
...more
in many ways i felt as if he was ashamed of his mexican heritage. he seems to uphold assimilation and westernization of thought, mind, etc. for that reason, i am not a fan.
In Richard Rodriguez's memoir, Hunger of Memory: The Education of Richard Rodriguez, Rodriguez does a brilliant job of painting a picture in his readers minds of what education meant to Native Americans, being the minority in a Sacramento school district. Throughout the course of the memoir, Rodriguez describes the hurtful behavior caused by his parents and his culture.
I enjoyed this novel and it spoke to me in the way that whenever I didn't feel like going to school, there is a child somewhe
In Richard Rodriguez's memoir, Hunger of Memory: The Education of Richard Rodriguez, Rodriguez does a brilliant job of painting a picture in his readers minds of what education meant to Native Americans, being the minority in a Sacramento school district. Throughout the course of the memoir, Rodriguez describes the hurtful behavior caused by his parents and his culture.
I enjoyed this novel and it spoke to me in the way that whenever I didn't feel like going to school, there is a child somewhere that envies my privileges of education. This memoir taught me to be thankful for the education that was given to me.
...more
Please, excuse me for being frank about this, but some of the reviewers missed the main point of the book.
Rodriguez is not writing about himself trying to leave his cultural heritage behind. He is writing about his struggle to keep his heritage, while being assimilated by another culture: The culture of higher (end) education. His struggle is grounded on his (working class) family being so far away from that when he started his journey, and also unintentionally pushing him away by taking from hi
Please, excuse me for being frank about this, but some of the reviewers missed the main point of the book.
Rodriguez is not writing about himself trying to leave his cultural heritage behind. He is writing about his struggle to keep his heritage, while being assimilated by another culture: The culture of higher (end) education. His struggle is grounded on his (working class) family being so far away from that when he started his journey, and also unintentionally pushing him away by taking from him the most important medium of relation: their language.
At the end of his journey he has come extremly far, and at the same time he must go back to square one. He has broken every educational ceiling there is, but still suffers from his inner disunity. Now that he has reached what his parents had in mind, when moving close to his very first school, he must try to revive his roots. This is extremly difficult, for his parents are (in a sense) still working class.
To round it up: His main struggle is about keeping his cultural heritage, while loosing the social heritage. And he did a pretty fine job in putting it into words.
If you are interested in this topic, I recommend Richard Hoggart's "The Uses of Literacy. Aspects of Working Class Life".
...more
I return to this book 8 years after I read if for the first time. Within minutes I find myself recalling the Sunday brunches my parents used to prepare for our entire family, the joyful sounds of my growing up in Virginia, after spending my early years in Eastern Europe. I intimately know the things Mr. Rodriguez writes about, because I've experienced them.
The book itself is an abstract approach to the original structure of an autobiography. It lacks the voluminous accounts of monthly or yearly
I return to this book 8 years after I read if for the first time. Within minutes I find myself recalling the Sunday brunches my parents used to prepare for our entire family, the joyful sounds of my growing up in Virginia, after spending my early years in Eastern Europe. I intimately know the things Mr. Rodriguez writes about, because I've experienced them.
The book itself is an abstract approach to the original structure of an autobiography. It lacks the voluminous accounts of monthly or yearly accomplishments (Colin Powell `My American Journey' or Bill Clinton's `My Life' come to mind). Rather, the author takes on a path of moral reflection on the time it took one boy to become a man and the education it took to transform one's identity. He assembles a combination of essays through which via a free flowing narrative, he conducts self-examination over the emergence of his `public' character and the replacement of his `private' persona.
But there is something else in this book. There is longing. Longing for the days when the 'sounds' of his family brought meaning and recognition for what he was meant to be, for where he was meant to go (or was that a childhood illusion?). A reader would find it difficult to ignore the author's emotional yearning for the past for a childhood now gone, when love, and family, and values, and identity made sense.
Mr. Rodriguez has done a superb job of capturing with words what many of us (first or second generation Americans) feel as members of families with similar backgrounds.
I highly recommend this book.
...more
This book has languished on my bookshelf for years, ranking high on the list of books I was ashamed never to have read. On the eve of my thirtieth birthday, I finally crossed it off the list. I could have told you that Rodriguez argues against bilingual education and against affirmative action. I could not have predicted how well-written the book is or how much I would enjoy it as a read. Some of Rodriguez’s arguments are rational – does affirmative action do enough to confront the class-based i
This book has languished on my bookshelf for years, ranking high on the list of books I was ashamed never to have read. On the eve of my thirtieth birthday, I finally crossed it off the list. I could have told you that Rodriguez argues against bilingual education and against affirmative action. I could not have predicted how well-written the book is or how much I would enjoy it as a read. Some of Rodriguez’s arguments are rational – does affirmative action do enough to confront the class-based inequalities of our society? No, it does not. Rodriguez criticizes the focus on affirmative action on higher education and argues that perhaps more could be done for to improve the quality of schooling at the primary and secondary levels. We need to create access to higher education in part by improving primary education. I give him that point. Does bilingual education prevent students from achieving a sense of public belonging? This is an argument I just don’t buy and find quite offensive. While the book serves in part as a defense and explanation of his political viewpoints, the memoir addresses what is for Rodriguez a deeper issue – in what ways has his cultural transformation and access to education altered his sense of self and his relationship to his family? How has the sense of loss of intimacy with his family gained through education provided the public sense of self necessary for his participation in society? I give this book four stars not because I agree with what Rodriguez has to say but because I appreciate the way he says it and I enjoyed reading it. The book engaged me and I’m glad I finally pulled it off the shelf and read my way through it.
...more
Richard Rodriguez is a man whose education bifurcated his life into a private life and a public life. In the public sphere he was driven to obtain an education that has led him to become one of the most interesting essayists of our time. His description of his inner life, especially his reading life is one of many exceptional aspects of this book. His liberation from the private sphere into the public, where he has become a literary light for others, was made possible in part by this reading lif
Richard Rodriguez is a man whose education bifurcated his life into a private life and a public life. In the public sphere he was driven to obtain an education that has led him to become one of the most interesting essayists of our time. His description of his inner life, especially his reading life is one of many exceptional aspects of this book. His liberation from the private sphere into the public, where he has become a literary light for others, was made possible in part by this reading life; a life driven by a compulsion to become part of the "public sphere" that was centered in the culture apart from his family. This was a part of his life that I personally identified with and believe that many individuals who love the reading life will also.
In this memoir he explores his own coming-of-age in an America that challenged him to understand what it is to be a Mexican American and what it is to be a Catholic in America. At the heart of the memoir is Rodríguez’s recognition that his is a position of alienation, a position that he accepts with resignation and regret. As the title of this collection of autobiographical pieces suggests, he remembers his early childhood with nostalgia, while acknowledging that his coming-of-age has resulted in his displacement from that simple, secure life.
Another center for his autobiography is language and the importance of it in his life. He did not speak English until he started to go to school and even then it was difficult for him to learn the language for it was not spoken at home. One exciting moment in his education occurred when three nuns from his grade school visited his home and encouraged his parents to support their children's English language skills. Although they were indifferent speakers of English, his parents from that point forward asked their children, Richard and his brother and sisters, to speak English each evening. Richard, through this practice and his own diligence in reading and writing, would go on to major in English in college eventually doing postgraduate work in Renaissance Studies.
He shares the hard work that all this entailed and his critical reaction to the growth of bi-lingual education. His courage in developing and maintaining an independent voice for his beliefs in this regard also help to make his story unique. In his view bilingual education prevents children from learning the public language that will be their passport to success in the public world, and he uses his own experience—being a bilingual child who was educated without bilingual education as it was introduced into the American school system in the 1960’s—as an example.
Rodríguez offers himself as another example in criticizing affirmative action programs. Turning down offers to teach at various post secondary educational institutions that he believed wanted to hire him simply because he was Latino, Rodríguez began what has been his persistent criticism of affirmative action policies in America. His uncompromising position in this matter led him to leave academia and pursue his writing skills as a journalist and essayist. His devotion to education in language and life helped him develop the voice that he shares in his journalistic and readable prose style.
I first encountered his voice while watching the News Hour on PBS where he was an essayist for many years. The style he demonstrated there is present on every page of his autobiography. I would highly recommend this for anyone interested in the development of a humane intellectual.
...more
This book has honestly become a sort of diary to me. Every single concept that Rodriguez writes about I can relate too. Many are surprised to see me so "into" a book of such topic. As a Mexican-american teenager, I can confidently say that this book is a true eye opener.
I enjoy seeing the openness with which Rodriguez speaks about his life, his beliefs, and his struggles. The amount of possible meanings for each topic extend over a wide range, I enjoy the juxtaposition of him as a person. He is
This book has honestly become a sort of diary to me. Every single concept that Rodriguez writes about I can relate too. Many are surprised to see me so "into" a book of such topic. As a Mexican-american teenager, I can confidently say that this book is a true eye opener.
I enjoy seeing the openness with which Rodriguez speaks about his life, his beliefs, and his struggles. The amount of possible meanings for each topic extend over a wide range, I enjoy the juxtaposition of him as a person. He is awkwardly, some may say, placed in a world where he doesn't belong. I disagree, this book is proof that he has earned his position. It describes in detail his success and his failure. I recommend this book and can truthfully say that I will be rereading it often, if not on end.
...more
This is an important book, and perhaps the most important book I've read in a while. In our society, we seldom differentiate between race and ethnicity, and we are quick to shy away from discussing class. As an educator, we repeatedly see income tied to standardized test results, yet no one wishes to discuss this. Well, not many do... other than Richard Rodriguez, who was against affirmative action but is honest enough to say how it simultaneously benefitted him and didn't go to those who most n
This is an important book, and perhaps the most important book I've read in a while. In our society, we seldom differentiate between race and ethnicity, and we are quick to shy away from discussing class. As an educator, we repeatedly see income tied to standardized test results, yet no one wishes to discuss this. Well, not many do... other than Richard Rodriguez, who was against affirmative action but is honest enough to say how it simultaneously benefitted him and didn't go to those who most needed it. In a thin volume, he beautifully discusses his experiences from childhood on, and includes skin color and other social taboos which make it like reading someone who is both acutely intellegent and poetic's diary. Lovely.
...more
Well-written enough to maybe convince you of his beliefs, but, at its core, just an autobiography about an "exception" that thinks himself the "rule." Tries to speak on issues that affect the Mexican/Latino population in the U.S. at large (bilingual education, affirmative action) while simultaneously distancing himself completely from his identity as Mexican. Uses his personal experience to make broad political statements. Again, well-written, but his experiences should not be taken as political
Well-written enough to maybe convince you of his beliefs, but, at its core, just an autobiography about an "exception" that thinks himself the "rule." Tries to speak on issues that affect the Mexican/Latino population in the U.S. at large (bilingual education, affirmative action) while simultaneously distancing himself completely from his identity as Mexican. Uses his personal experience to make broad political statements. Again, well-written, but his experiences should not be taken as political fact.
...more
His honesty seems to be wrapped in his revising of this story to ensure that its truth comes across not only to himself, but to his readers as well. Definitely an educational type of autobiography, but more for the reason that education itself has played such a humungous role in his life. There is such a refreshing and challenging thing about reading how passionate and convinced he is about his stance on issues like affirmative action and what it
Undeniably well written and almost lyrically so.
His honesty seems to be wrapped in his revising of this story to ensure that its truth comes across not only to himself, but to his readers as well. Definitely an educational type of autobiography, but more for the reason that education itself has played such a humungous role in his life. There is such a refreshing and challenging thing about reading how passionate and convinced he is about his stance on issues like affirmative action and what it means to be minority. I admire his seeking out what it means and attempting to reconcile his peace with it regardless of his position in it that he was indefinitely born with.
I enjoyed his reflections in the last portion personally, just to hear his written voice in its most vulnerable and its acknowledgement of where he's been and where he is and how the two meet in such a strange place.
I give it a 3 only because I would probably not have had the individual drive to pick up and read this on my own. I will probably only look to it now for the underlined pieces that impact me. But the notions he brings up and personal accounts he risks sharing are well worth listening to and bringing into conversations with others.
...more
I could give this book 3.5 stars, or 4.1 stars, or 3.8 stars, or 3.2-4.3 stars, because Rodriguez is hard to love and hate. That said: I did enjoy reading it; Rodriguez writes with aplomb he says he doesn't actually have, and whiteness I know he kinda resents. In reality, Hunger of Memory should be, How Did I Get So White, Mom? And I know the answer, son: motherf*cker, you can't give white people that much f*ckin credit, motherf*cker. IDC how prevailing YOU THINK that alabaster is - Rodriguez co
I could give this book 3.5 stars, or 4.1 stars, or 3.8 stars, or 3.2-4.3 stars, because Rodriguez is hard to love and hate. That said: I did enjoy reading it; Rodriguez writes with aplomb he says he doesn't actually have, and whiteness I know he kinda resents. In reality, Hunger of Memory should be, How Did I Get So White, Mom? And I know the answer, son: motherf*cker, you can't give white people that much f*ckin credit, motherf*cker. IDC how prevailing YOU THINK that alabaster is - Rodriguez confuses erudition with assimilation, and acculturation with plain attendance. And while there's elements of both in both, if you're NOT saying "F*CK School," then what're you saying? Because he isn't saying anything, I feel like. Which is, doy, what he f*cking says, when he says how a scholarship is "a dummy mouthing the opinions of others." So then how am I to adjudicate on this as a fellow brownface person, in grad school my damn self? Like, for real. fuck(ing) (love) this book.
...more
I can relate because his point is this: our immigrant parents came to this country for a better opportunity for the kids. Once us kids benefit from that opportunity through advanced education or high-end careers, the unfortunate downside of success is a bit of distance from your roots, whether you like it or not. You simply grow because you're exposed to so many different things, as any young adult does. The way his story unfolds makes you feel for him and understand the situation. In the begin
I can relate because his point is this: our immigrant parents came to this country for a better opportunity for the kids. Once us kids benefit from that opportunity through advanced education or high-end careers, the unfortunate downside of success is a bit of distance from your roots, whether you like it or not. You simply grow because you're exposed to so many different things, as any young adult does. The way his story unfolds makes you feel for him and understand the situation. In the beginning I didn't think I would like the book (I too felt bitter like one of the other reviewers), but after a chapter or two I couldn't put it down. His self awareness is courageous. And for those who don't like his stance on affirmative action/bilingual education, his point was merely that governments were missing the real issue, and that's fixing/investing in K-12 education. All the higher-ed based affirmative action in the world won't help kids who can't read.
...more
As a Mexican-American experiencing a similar childhood to Richard Rodriguez (my last name also being Rodriguez) I found this book extremely offensive. Despite the controversial aspect, fighting his culture vs. accepting it, the book consisted of constant complaints. This book presents an extremely negative view on Hispanic society. As a whole, I was extremely disappointed with the "renowned" Hunger of Memory.
Richard Rodriguez is an American writer who became famous as the author of Hunger of Memory: The Education of Richard Rodriguez (1982). His work has appeared in Harper's, The American Scholar, the Los Angeles Times Magazine, and The New Republic. Richard's awards include the Frankel Medal from the National Endowment for the Humanities and the International Journalism Award from the World Affairs C
Richard Rodriguez is an American writer who became famous as the author of Hunger of Memory: The Education of Richard Rodriguez (1982). His work has appeared in Harper's, The American Scholar, the Los Angeles Times Magazine, and The New Republic. Richard's awards include the Frankel Medal from the National Endowment for the Humanities and the International Journalism Award from the World Affairs Council of California. He has been nominated for the Pulitzer Prize in non-fiction; and the National Book Critics' Award.
...more