"Written by Charles Wesley Allen from Red Cloud's reminiscences told to Sam Deon, and repeated to Allen"
Red Cloud was the only Native American leader ever to win a war against the United States Army. Here, for the first time in print, is Red Cloud's "as-told-to" autobiography in which he shares the story of his early years.
Paperback
,
222 pages
Published
January 1st 1997
by Montana Historical Society Press
A very unique book but definitely not an autobiography. But kudos to the author for the hard work of publishing this text, I was very pleased to find it in existence.
Most of Red Cloud's story has been published 'third hand'. That is, he gave his story orally to a friend who then (without Red Cloud's knowledge) told them to the first writer, who wrote them into a manuscript. This manuscript was never published and then was forgotten about for 100 years where it was found by historians. The autho
A very unique book but definitely not an autobiography. But kudos to the author for the hard work of publishing this text, I was very pleased to find it in existence.
Most of Red Cloud's story has been published 'third hand'. That is, he gave his story orally to a friend who then (without Red Cloud's knowledge) told them to the first writer, who wrote them into a manuscript. This manuscript was never published and then was forgotten about for 100 years where it was found by historians. The author of this current text then worked tirelessly to corroborate the original manuscript and then has published it in the form you see here. Hardly an autobiography. However, since no other true autobiographical texts exist of any Native American leaders of the era, this is the best we can hope for in the entire human catalogue. For this reason alone, we are looking at a very special circumstance.
Most of the chapters are events in Red Cloud's life BEFORE his wars with the Americans (apparently Red Cloud didn't consider war with the whites very honorable and thus refused to give it credence in his own life story). To me this is why the book has at least some value. It reveals much of the traditional way of command and conquer on the ancient plains and tells how the varying tribes fought and raided each other. All invaluable information.
However, Red Cloud's voice is not here. The whole thing is written in the third person. Thus it reads like a wikipedia page. There really isn't any literary value in this respect. This disappointed me so much. The personality of Red Cloud the man is not here. We are simply left with an explanation of events in time with little or no color added to them. You only get a half-image of the man. There is no access to how he felt or why he was motivated to do things. This access to emotion and motivation is the only reasons autobiographies are interesting to read in my opinion. These omissions are glaring.
Furthermore, the author of the current texts adds much of his own commentary. Most of this is great. However, the author leaves no way for us to tell when we are reading the original manuscript and when we are reading his own thoughts or research. It's all just meshed together. This is enraging.
There are simply too many hands molding Red Cloud's oral stories into the form we get them here to take this text very seriously. Genocide is genocide as our forefathers left little of the Native American culture intact for us to appreciate and learn from. Red Cloud's autobiography is just a glimmer, it's just so so so bittersweet.
...more
No matter how you slice it, it's still a bit of a stretch to label this an autobiography.... It's more of a puzzle, put together by many disparate pieces spanning decades, and what we get is a vague third-person portrait of the man.