This book was converted from its physical edition to the digital format by a community of volunteers. You may find it for free on the web. Purchase of the Kindle edition includes wireless delivery.
In 1892, in the town of Meaford, Ontario, Margaret Marshall Saunders was introduced to Beautiful Joe -a mongrel dog that had been cruelly mutilated by its owner. The author was i
This book was converted from its physical edition to the digital format by a community of volunteers. You may find it for free on the web. Purchase of the Kindle edition includes wireless delivery.
In 1892, in the town of Meaford, Ontario, Margaret Marshall Saunders was introduced to Beautiful Joe -a mongrel dog that had been cruelly mutilated by its owner. The author was inspired to write this true story to emphasize the plight of domestic animals everywhere. Upon publication, Beautiful Joe quickly became a Canadian classic, enchanting readers of all ages. Although Margaret Saunders relocated Beautiful Joe to a fictional town in Maine, readers know the story is actually based in Meaford, where a park and monument have been dedicated to the dog's memory
...more
This is an old favorite. From "Beautiful Joes" point of view. It was an amazing book! Inspiring, simple, touching.The rough start at life for Joe really makes you think. How your life is, how his was.How it would be like for an animal.What they possibly think, would feel.I am quite fond with all the characters.Each one reaches out to you.You truly feel like you know them.The care in the book is amazing.Like I said, the book was touching.And it was a true story! It made me eager to read Beautiful
This is an old favorite. From "Beautiful Joes" point of view. It was an amazing book! Inspiring, simple, touching.The rough start at life for Joe really makes you think. How your life is, how his was.How it would be like for an animal.What they possibly think, would feel.I am quite fond with all the characters.Each one reaches out to you.You truly feel like you know them.The care in the book is amazing.Like I said, the book was touching.And it was a true story! It made me eager to read Beautiful Joes Paradise. The second book. Where Beautiful Joe now rules an animal haven/heaven. But when his master dies, he is bound by loyalty and must give up his "throne" (position) to return to his masters side once more.I loved the book and never tire of reading it.Loved it, and no better words for me to describe it.I have read the book over 5 times and cannot stop reading the last words.I love how Saunders tells the story of the dog.Just...fantastic.
...more
My mom introduced me this story when I was only about 8 years old, as I was an animal empath all of my life. Keeping with the tradition of Black Beauty, one has to understamd that this book was written more for simple people who didn't understand in the late 1800's and early 1900's that animals had souls and could feel pain. Marshall Saunders does an excellent job of teaching that it isn't easy living at the mercy of cruel humans in the same way as Black Beauty and I love books that are told fro
My mom introduced me this story when I was only about 8 years old, as I was an animal empath all of my life. Keeping with the tradition of Black Beauty, one has to understamd that this book was written more for simple people who didn't understand in the late 1800's and early 1900's that animals had souls and could feel pain. Marshall Saunders does an excellent job of teaching that it isn't easy living at the mercy of cruel humans in the same way as Black Beauty and I love books that are told from the animals perspective.
A wonderful tale of Joe on his journey from birth to a cold, cruel world on to a comfy life with a kind mistress. The print book I have has a brindle pit bull looking dog with cropped ears that I believe was published in the 1930's. I have read this book numerous times in my life and I am glad to have a digital copy, as well.
...more
"My name is Beautiful Joe, and I am a brown dog of medium size."
Beautiful Joe: The Autobiography of a Dog
was written in 1893 by Margaret Marshall Saunders. The author used a male pen name because she feared she would not be taken seriously as a woman writer. I picked up a copy at a used book sale on a strength of a recommendation of a friend, and while I enjoyed the story of a loyal dog who comes to a loving family after having been savagely mistreated, I think I would have enjoyed it more if I
"My name is Beautiful Joe, and I am a brown dog of medium size."
Beautiful Joe: The Autobiography of a Dog
was written in 1893 by Margaret Marshall Saunders. The author used a male pen name because she feared she would not be taken seriously as a woman writer. I picked up a copy at a used book sale on a strength of a recommendation of a friend, and while I enjoyed the story of a loyal dog who comes to a loving family after having been savagely mistreated, I think I would have enjoyed it more if I had read it when I was a child. It is written in the voice of the dog. Comparisons could certainly be made to Black Beauty. It's my understanding that the story itself is true, that there really was a Beautiful Joe who was saved from a cruel owner, and that the book was written to encourage children to treat animals with kindness. The book is interesting for a view of people's attitudes toward and uses of animals over a hundred years ago. The author is clearly disturbed for example by how some cart horses were worked to death in cities. It would be interesting to see what animal causes the author would choose to champion if the book were written today.
...more
This was one of my favorite books when I was a youngster. It tells the story of a dog who is owned by a cruel master (he cuts his ears and tail off) before being rescued by a kind family. Told from the dog's perspective, it is a compelling and poignant read that is both joyful and tear producing depending. Highly recommended to all children ten and up.
I can't believe this book had no readers on Goodreads. This is a book written in the same manner as Black Beauty to raise awareness of animal cruelty. An influential book in my life.
I can't believe I made it 32 years without knowing about Beautiful Joe. I so wish I had been introduced to this book as a child - I can only imagine how many times I'd have read it between then and now. I won't make that same mistake with my daughter. I'm going to buy a copy of this for us and always keep it around. I'll read it to her in a few years and then hopefully a few years later she'll be reading it herself.
I would have liked this book to be five times as long as it is. It's rare to fin
I can't believe I made it 32 years without knowing about Beautiful Joe. I so wish I had been introduced to this book as a child - I can only imagine how many times I'd have read it between then and now. I won't make that same mistake with my daughter. I'm going to buy a copy of this for us and always keep it around. I'll read it to her in a few years and then hopefully a few years later she'll be reading it herself.
I would have liked this book to be five times as long as it is. It's rare to find a book
that
good. So many things ran through my mind - how, on the surface, this book is about pretty much nothing and yet, underneath, it's about so, so much. How I wish I was Miss Laura! How I wish I had a Dingley Farm!
I don't know that there is an animal lover on planet earth, no matter the animal, that could find a bad word to say about Beautiful Joe. This is a keeper if there ever was one!
...more
I was pleasantly surprised to find a book written in a dog's voice in 1893, and I absolutely loved it. And the voice - Beautiful Joe's - is indeed a beautiful voice. His voice is genuine and loveable, and his perspective is believable. The book also gives an historical account of the way animals were treated in America at that time. I found it sad that so little has changed since then in respect to the abuse, neglect, and abandonment of animals and the lack of laws to protect them. Beautiful Joe
I was pleasantly surprised to find a book written in a dog's voice in 1893, and I absolutely loved it. And the voice - Beautiful Joe's - is indeed a beautiful voice. His voice is genuine and loveable, and his perspective is believable. The book also gives an historical account of the way animals were treated in America at that time. I found it sad that so little has changed since then in respect to the abuse, neglect, and abandonment of animals and the lack of laws to protect them. Beautiful Joe has made me look at our three beloved dogs in a new way. When I look into their faces I remember Joe's voice, and I believe I have a much better idea what my dogs are thinking or what they might be wishing they could say to me. Many thanks to the author for writing this book.
...more
My aunt gave this book to us this summer and said that she had read and loved it when she was about 8 years old. It is about a dog who was born on a farm with a very abusive owner. The dog is soon rescued and taken in by a loving family. Kaitlyn loved it and always begged me to read more. We were instructed that the book is to share with all our cousins but Kaitlyn doesn't want to give it up. She is now starting to read it a second time on her own. My aunt tells me that there is a cemetery in On
My aunt gave this book to us this summer and said that she had read and loved it when she was about 8 years old. It is about a dog who was born on a farm with a very abusive owner. The dog is soon rescued and taken in by a loving family. Kaitlyn loved it and always begged me to read more. We were instructed that the book is to share with all our cousins but Kaitlyn doesn't want to give it up. She is now starting to read it a second time on her own. My aunt tells me that there is a cemetery in Ontario where the real Beautiful Joe is buried. She says many other animal lovers have buried their pets there too. Anyway, thank you Auntie Donna. We loved Beautiful Joe.
...more
This book was written in 1893 by
Margaret Marshall Saunders
. What a remarkable, compassionate author she is. The story is of a dog, Beautiful Joe, and is told by the dog. The entire story focuses on his life and the the humane treatment of animals. I just loved the last sentence of the book:
"Boys and girls, be kind to dumb animals, not only because you will lose nothing by it, but because you ought to; for they were placed on the earth by the same Kind Hand that made all living creatures."
Beautiful Joe is the story of a dog, a mongrel whose first owner abused him, going so far as to chop off his ears and tail. He was rescued and went on to live a much happier life. The author of this story, Margaret Marshall Saunders1 met the real Beautiful Joe while visiting her brother in law and his wife, the inspiration for Laura in the book. She was touched by Joe’s story, and having recently read Black Beauty2 decided to write “a dog’s own tale”.
A lot of comparisons to Black Beauty might be
Beautiful Joe is the story of a dog, a mongrel whose first owner abused him, going so far as to chop off his ears and tail. He was rescued and went on to live a much happier life. The author of this story, Margaret Marshall Saunders1 met the real Beautiful Joe while visiting her brother in law and his wife, the inspiration for Laura in the book. She was touched by Joe’s story, and having recently read Black Beauty2 decided to write “a dog’s own tale”.
A lot of comparisons to Black Beauty might be made, but to my mind this is much more simply written than Black Beauty, although I suppose I haven’t read that one in a long while. I could be misremembering.
Beautiful Joe is also much more didactic, its main purpose is to highlight the abuses and animal cruelty that were rampant at the time. Different chapters cover different episodes in Joe’s life, and sometimes cover different animals that were mistreated. Many were rescued by the same family that take in Joe, but some don’t get that happy ending. A lot of the dialogue between the characters is about how animals should be treated, and why they should be treated better. The book was originally an entry into a Human Society competition, and that focus is very much in evidence.
I liked a lot about this book, but it is very much of its time, and the author, and the family she writes about are clearly in a position of privilege in society. They may not be the richest, but they certainly don’t have to worry about where the next meal is coming from, and a lot of their attitudes come across as very paternalistic, if only those poor people knew we could cure them. That grated a little on me.
But aside from that it is a certainly a touching story, and any dog lover will probably enjoy it.
...more
BEAUTIFUL JOE originated from the same era and sensibilities as the more famous BLACK BEAUTY. Like the world’s best-known horse novel, BEAUTIFUL JOE tells a story from the perspective of an animal (this time a dog), with the intent of instilling humane values in its readers. Unlike BLACK BEAUTY, however, JOE is not a classic in writing style, and reads more like a morality play—attempting to cram as many lessons as possible into the text—than an actual story that will hold readers’ attention.
Ma
BEAUTIFUL JOE originated from the same era and sensibilities as the more famous BLACK BEAUTY. Like the world’s best-known horse novel, BEAUTIFUL JOE tells a story from the perspective of an animal (this time a dog), with the intent of instilling humane values in its readers. Unlike BLACK BEAUTY, however, JOE is not a classic in writing style, and reads more like a morality play—attempting to cram as many lessons as possible into the text—than an actual story that will hold readers’ attention.
Many of the tenants of our modern humane advocacy movement arose in the Victorian era, and BEAUTIFUL JOE is an interesting study of the state of animals at that time. Some issues are thankfully of the past—such as the feathered hat fashion which saw untold numbers of wild birds slaughtered for the fad. Some issues, we are still battling—the cruelty of the steel-jawed
leghold trap
is lamented here, as is the production of white veal—which in the book’s time was accomplished by letting a calf slowly bleed out alive, and in today’s time by severely confining a calf and feeding an iron-poor diet. It was interesting to see just how long in the tooth the campaign against veal is, and is perhaps a reason why many meat lovers paradoxically reject veal, while eating many other animal foods which come from just as cruel conditions.
Interestingly, we encounter an ethically-motivated vegetarian in this story, a rarity in both novels old and new. The author does keep a bit of derision on the man, who is clearly described as an eccentric. Nonetheless, he tells Laura, Beautiful Joe’s young keeper and the principal human character,
“My dear young lady, if you could see what I have seen, you’d never eat another bit of meat all the days of your life.”
While today, most vegetarians would be referring to factory farming—an invention of the post-WWII era—in Victorian times, this meant the arduous sea and train voyages made to take animals to slaughterhouses, and then the hideous conditions they often faced once there. Today, cruel and arduous trips to slaughter are still a serious animal welfare issue, although in the continental US it is done with
tractor-trailers
and the animals’ time in the slaughterhouse, while now subject to some regulation, is still
fraught with abuses.
However, we learn that this vegetarian is not as set in his ways as others:
“It’s a possible thing to raise healthy stock, treat it kindly, kill it mercifully, eat it decently. When men do that, I, for one, will cease to be a vegetarian.”
While some of today’s ethical vegetarians would agree, many would not—that the act of stealing life from a healthy young animal is in itself wrong when done simply for the pleasure of one’s palate.
An interesting aside-- Miss Laura can’t bear to hear of the suffering farm animals endure to become meat, yet she is eager to hear an uncle’s hunting stories, despite the uncle decrying them himself as cruel. (Perhaps she only shuts their ears to the suffering to which she herself contributes?) The same uncle, we learn, is reformed in his ways—he has given up hunting and trapping for good. I found a great deal of dark humor when I read this line regarding the character:
“Do you know, Laura, he won’t even kill a fowl for dinner. He gives it to one of the men to do.” …“Blessed are the merciful,” said Miss Laura, throwing her arm over her uncle’s shoulder. “I love you, dear Uncle John, because you are so kind to every living thing.”
To use a very un-Victorian expression, LOL. Imagine this compassion applied to any other moral dilemma: “I’m a very honest person, I would never rob anyone. Instead, I pay somebody else to steal things, and then just receive the stolen merchandise.”
Vegetarian ethics still had a way to go, as did some of the other values presented in this book which modern humane sensibilities would now find objectionable. Dogs and cats are free to roam, even in town. An exotic parrot is captured in the wild and sold to the family. Small pets are bought, bred, and sold. A street performer has a circus-style act starring monkeys dressed in clothes and doing foolish tricks.
And of course, there was a bit of Victorian-era idealistic silliness, even though most of it is good intentioned. For example, we meet an owner who teaches her cat to stop hunting small animals by expressing her disappointment in the cat—one might as well teach a baby to never cry.
That said, BEAUTIFUL JOE remains remarkably ahead of its time overall. As noted before, multiple humane issues are discussed—issues which even today are ignored by most “dog and cat” people and the media directed toward them. Horses and farm animals are extensively discussed and advocated for—perhaps not surprisingly, as horses were certainly the most visible animals of the time period, and experienced all manner of treatment in their role as the primary form of transportation. The issues relating to dogs and cats are also of course extensively discussed through the observation of Joe, who escaped an abusive master and found a loving home. Even the origins of
ear cropping
—it was developed by dogfighters and later adopted into the “standards” of multiple breeds—is touched upon.
While we can look back at many aspects of humane thought in BEAUTIFUL JOE and feel we have improved things—or at the very least made the public more aware of them—there is one aspect in which today’s animal lovers could take home a lesson from Saunders. We read about a farmer who has a vicious dog who is being kept chained because of his propensity to attack people and animals alike. Regarding the dog, the farmer states:
“I’m going to kill him. I’ve no use for a bad dog. Have plenty of animals, I say, and treat them kindly, but if there’s a vicious one among them, put it out of the way, for it is a constant danger to man and beast. It’s queer how ugly some people are about their dogs. They’ll keep them, no matter how they worry other people, and even when they’re snatching the bread out of their neighbors’ mouths.”
While the dog’s destruction is presented as a sad necessity, not even Laura, the text’s most vociferous animal lover, objects to it. Today, of course, we have a small but vocal crowd that values dangerous dogs above all else, including the lives of both humans and other dogs. There are
enormous efforts
to rescue dogs who have permanently disfigured and even killed people, and
appalling disregard
for the victims practiced even by some animal care professionals. During BEAUTIFUL JOE’s era, when deaths by dog were still
exceedingly rare,
humane people could probably scarcely imagine the situation we are in today, with circa 30 Americans being mauled to death by vicious dogs each and every year.
...more
Another excellent book that my grandmother gave me. A beautiful, sensitive and sad story told from the perspective of an abused dog. This story was written to strike up interest in animal's rights in the early 1900's.
Read this as a child, loved it and have never forgotten it was a favorite, although my memory of the details is dim. I do know Joe stole my heart. Have wanted to reread it for a long time.
I found an older copy of this book as a gift for a nephew, and took time to re-read it before gifting. My mother read it to us when we were children...perhaps I was 8? It made a good and lasting impression, but I wanted to see how it read now.
It was revolutionary in its time and resulted in many advances in dog care, as it was inspired by Black Beauty. Joe was a real dog.
What is interesting about reading it today is the appreciation one gets for the advances since it was first penned, througho
I found an older copy of this book as a gift for a nephew, and took time to re-read it before gifting. My mother read it to us when we were children...perhaps I was 8? It made a good and lasting impression, but I wanted to see how it read now.
It was revolutionary in its time and resulted in many advances in dog care, as it was inspired by Black Beauty. Joe was a real dog.
What is interesting about reading it today is the appreciation one gets for the advances since it was first penned, throughout society. It was written in Canada, but reflects it's time in the US. Women did not have the vote; the government did not take any responsibility for roads...those are 2 examples.
For folks both liberal and conservative, it shows a glimpse of the way things were, and the things folks predicted "if there were change". Reading in the context of living in that change is useful.
Understand that some of the "information" is now misinformation, as veterinary science has advanced. For example, giving a dog plenty of clean water is not going to prevent rabies. However, it helps us not take for granted the power vaccines and such have given us to help and care for our pets.
...more
I read BEAUTIFUL JOE as a child. I wept through the beginning until Joe escapes his cruel first master. My uncle was never able to get past page 20 or so. Old family story about that.
I was fond of animal stories for a period. I remember enjoying one written from the point of view of a peregrine falcon. Cannot remember the name.
I moved on from animals when I discovered Franklin W. Dixon's The Hardy Boys. I devoured the entire series of books. Even skipped school a few times to stay home and rea
I read BEAUTIFUL JOE as a child. I wept through the beginning until Joe escapes his cruel first master. My uncle was never able to get past page 20 or so. Old family story about that.
I was fond of animal stories for a period. I remember enjoying one written from the point of view of a peregrine falcon. Cannot remember the name.
I moved on from animals when I discovered Franklin W. Dixon's The Hardy Boys. I devoured the entire series of books. Even skipped school a few times to stay home and read when I found a new addition to the series.
...more
My grade two teacher read this book to our class and I will never forget the impact it had on me. I remember trying hard not to cry as she read it, but borrowed a copy from the library so I could read it at home and cry privately. I found an old copy at a book sale years later and couldn't wait to read it to my own children. Sadly, they could not garner the same enthusiasm for it as I, but patiently listened during our bedtime reading rituals. I hope I made it up to them by honoring their choice
My grade two teacher read this book to our class and I will never forget the impact it had on me. I remember trying hard not to cry as she read it, but borrowed a copy from the library so I could read it at home and cry privately. I found an old copy at a book sale years later and couldn't wait to read it to my own children. Sadly, they could not garner the same enthusiasm for it as I, but patiently listened during our bedtime reading rituals. I hope I made it up to them by honoring their choices!
...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
This is one of the few books I read as a child that made it to my "read" list. Being a "dog person" even as a child, this book was one of the first real books I remember reading, and was given to me by my mother for a collection of books she had as a child. I was given this book as a gift a few years ago, after mentioning how it was one of my favorite childhood books, and made the mistake of trying to re-read it. I got through the first 5 pages and realized the book would never be the same, and
This is one of the few books I read as a child that made it to my "read" list. Being a "dog person" even as a child, this book was one of the first real books I remember reading, and was given to me by my mother for a collection of books she had as a child. I was given this book as a gift a few years ago, after mentioning how it was one of my favorite childhood books, and made the mistake of trying to re-read it. I got through the first 5 pages and realized the book would never be the same, and would probably not only not revere it, but wouldn't like it any more if I continued to read. I stopped on page 5 and haven't picked it up since.
Being around the age of 6 when I read this book, my memories of the plot are somewhat fuzzy, and the 5 pages I reread tell me they are definitely viewed through the eyes of a child. To me this book was a story of triumph. The story is told primarily through the eyes of Joe, the dog who is everything but beautiful. He was not wanted as a puppy and his crook of an owner was also violent. In a rage he cropped Joe's ears so close to his head the metal scraped his head, and his tale and way to communicate his opinion was also taken. A passer-by heard him scream and begged the milkman to give him the puppy, which he reluctantly did. This book is how a good family taught this dog that not all people are evil and out to do him harm and also how our our misdeeds in life eventually come back to haunt us.
...more
When I was five years old my mother bought me this book at a goodwill in louisville for five cents. i remember seeing the picture of beautiful joe on the cover and found myself wanting to know why his little ears were cropped. the copy i had had been beaten up itself - the spine was held together with masking tape.
it was the first real book i read and i've read it many times throughout my life. as michael and i ready ourselves for a child, i thought it would be good to re-read this book. i'm su
When I was five years old my mother bought me this book at a goodwill in louisville for five cents. i remember seeing the picture of beautiful joe on the cover and found myself wanting to know why his little ears were cropped. the copy i had had been beaten up itself - the spine was held together with masking tape.
it was the first real book i read and i've read it many times throughout my life. as michael and i ready ourselves for a child, i thought it would be good to re-read this book. i'm sure i will be reading it to our little peanut at some point.
******
24 march 2013
Just finished re-reading Beautiful Joe. I started reading it late last night after being drawn to it on a bookshelf in our guest bedroom. Michael and I now have a daughter who recently turned two. I will most certainly be sharing this with our precious Ketevan when she is a little older. As a child this book instilled in me a great love and empathy for animals, especially dogs, that I feel to this day.
The book is written from the POV of Beautiful Joe, a dog who was mutilated by a cruel man and saved by a kind family who healed both his physical and spiritual wounds. It is a tale of redemption, a tale of great faith in all that is good in this world and how sharing one's life and love with man's best friend makes one a better person. I absolutely adore this book and have since I was a very young girl. I can hardly wait to share it with my darling girl.
...more
Wow this was painful to read. It's a kids classic, so I thought I would rip through it pretty quick...but no...
Beautiful Joe is the story of a dog in his own words. Think Black Beauty if you've ever read the book or watched the movie. The only difference is book really encompasses all kinds of animals, rather than just focusing on one type.
So Beautiful Joe is a dog who was abused by his first master. Had his ears and tail chopped off with an axe because the guy got in a bad mood. Luckily for him
Wow this was painful to read. It's a kids classic, so I thought I would rip through it pretty quick...but no...
Beautiful Joe is the story of a dog in his own words. Think Black Beauty if you've ever read the book or watched the movie. The only difference is book really encompasses all kinds of animals, rather than just focusing on one type.
So Beautiful Joe is a dog who was abused by his first master. Had his ears and tail chopped off with an axe because the guy got in a bad mood. Luckily for him someone with a better heart came along just as it happened, heard the noise poor Joe was making, and rescued him after laying the owner down low. The gentleman we later learn is named Harry, takes Joe to his cousin's house (farm, really. This all takes place out in the country) where he is visiting and the family soon sets him to rights.
Now this family has a thing for all animals. They have quite the menagerie going at their home: horses, dogs, birds, a cat, cows, guinea pigs, you name it there's probably one kicking around the property that these folks have saved. And honestly it warms the heart to think that there are people like that out there.
The rest of the story is Joe telling us about his life with these people, and the stories he hears along the way about the myriad ways people are cruel and abusive to animals. Some things are typical and you would expect, and some things, if true, chill your blood.
It's a really good book, but I would have liked it better if not for a few things. First off, it's the wrong choice of book for me. I consider myself a kind hearted soul, and it was hard for me to read the abuses that the animals suffered in the book. Even though they're fictional, the abuses they undertake are quite real.
The other fact is that it is steeped in Christianity. Always referring to how Gad made man and beast to be such-n-such and not so-n-so. Not a bad thing by any stretch of the imagination, I can see where it would have installed some good morals in the kiddies reading it when it first came out, but if you're not a religious person it does tend to hamper the reading I find.
That and the fact that every time people were talking about animals, be it as a whole or an individual, they were always "poor dumb beasts". And then the animals would be lauded for their intelligence. Can't decide if that's ironic or hypocritical...
So all in all I did like Beautiful Joe. It is a touching, heart warming, and at times fun story. Worth picking up if you're interested in animal stories, I just would have like it better if it wasn't for the aforementioned factors.
...more
I've been looking for this book for
years
. The last time I read it, must have been in 1983. That was when I was still in school and all I could remember was the shelf from which I fetched it and the dog on the cover! The scene that's haunted me ever since (and which is why I really wanted to read it again) was when young Joe goes to hide in the bramble bushes to die ... the rest was just a haze (except, of course, that a dog wrote the book, which my mother thought very funny). So, what a pleasur
I've been looking for this book for
years
. The last time I read it, must have been in 1983. That was when I was still in school and all I could remember was the shelf from which I fetched it and the dog on the cover! The scene that's haunted me ever since (and which is why I really wanted to read it again) was when young Joe goes to hide in the bramble bushes to die ... the rest was just a haze (except, of course, that a dog wrote the book, which my mother thought very funny). So, what a pleasure to hunt it down on GoodReads and find out what happened in the end.
Looking at it from an adult’s perspective, it seems like a bit of a tedious story. Although it seems good, it’s probably more entertaining for children than for someone like myself who’s looking for a story line, rather than a series of anecdotes that are not quite believable. I was also surprised to see the use of “waked up” (amongst other serious editorial faults). Could this be due to bad proofing or the fact that they spoke different English in 1903? This in addition to the virtual patriarchal, moral tone could make it quite laughable for the teenager of today - especially if one thinks of how important horses were thén compared to now-a-days! As a child, I really enjoyed it. But now … well, I’m disappointed.
...more
Beautiful Joe
has been compared to the groundbreaking
Black Beauty
since its publication in 1893. This first person story of an abused dog runs many parallels to
Black Beauty
and Margaret Marshall Saunders made no secret of having been inspired and greatly influenced by the horse novel. The two even met comparable success.
Black Beauty
was already famous and
Beautiful Joe
soon became the best-selling Canadian novel ever. (Though the true story it is loosely based on took place in Canada, the nov
Beautiful Joe
has been compared to the groundbreaking
Black Beauty
since its publication in 1893. This first person story of an abused dog runs many parallels to
Black Beauty
and Margaret Marshall Saunders made no secret of having been inspired and greatly influenced by the horse novel. The two even met comparable success.
Black Beauty
was already famous and
Beautiful Joe
soon became the best-selling Canadian novel ever. (Though the true story it is loosely based on took place in Canada, the novel is set in Maine.)
Like so many modern day successes in books, these two are divided by a great chasm that is rarely acknowledged: One author was a superb writer: One was not.
Beautiful Joe
follows a narrative so heavy-handed and explanatory that preaching is too soft a word. It's like being hit in the face with a sandbag over and over again while someone shouts at you, "Do you get it now?!"
Yet, even with Ms. Saunders' ham-fisted, long-winded, ranting at her reader, by the end of the book, I'm not sure I did get her message. (Clearly, I'm just as slow and ignorant as she imagined her audience to be.)
Beautiful Joe
is a mind-numbing sermon on how human beings must stop being so cruel to animals and all God's creatures deserve kindness and compassion. Got it so far. Then, there is also the dated nature of the text to be considered. Yes, the book is very old and this should be taken into account for any modern review. Got that too. What I fail to understand is how
Beautiful Joe
ever struck such a cord, ever reached such animal-loving masses, ever got anyone to take it seriously, when nearly every animal kindness preaching human character (and all the characters in the book preach just as much as the author) are abusive to animals themselves.
The examples are rampant but here are a few. Main characters, the good guys: shoot their own dogs because they were "bad tempered" and growled at them, poison cats by prying open their mouths and pouring potassium cyanide on their tongues, whip dogs and ponies as part of their "training," hunt, trap, and set packs of dogs on wild animals, and all the time preach kindness to the animal kingdom, wild and domestic.
Miss Laura, the heroine of the story and Beautiful Joe's teenage mistress, beats her six-week-old Fox Terrier puppy with a bootlace when she finds him chewing her father's hat. This is followed by a quick reassurance to the reader in case you thought the angelic Miss Laura was mean to dogs:
"She never struck a little dog with her hand or a stick. She said clubs were for big dogs and switches for little dogs, if one had to use them."
Ohhh. . . . Now I get it. Of course. Nice girl. She would never beat him with a
stick
. Heavens no. Only big dogs should be beaten with clubs.
But, you protest, dated book? That was the way it was then? Everyone thought you had to hit a dog if you wanted to train it?
I'm a dog trainer myself and have been for many years. I've spent over fifteen years studying new, established, and antiquated methods—from whip and club to bridge signals and the No Change Response System. I've researched historical training and working dogs going back well before 1893. Beating a dog to "train" it was
not
a universally accepted technique at the time and positive training methods did exist.
These were the best methods to Ms. Saunders, however, and—since all the good guys in
Beautiful Joe
share her views and preach her sermon—that's how dogs were trained by kindly owners in her book.
Despite the painful writing (worse than the brutal events it portrays), endless sermons, and shocking contradictions,
Beautiful Joe
did make changes for the better in the way people treated and related to animals and animal welfare around the turn of the century. For that alone it deserves to still be on our shelves. Though perhaps not the same one as
Black Beauty
, which rises hooves and paws above the rest as the pioneering, and outstanding, first person animal story that started well organized animal welfare campaigns in the first place.
BEAUTIFUL JOE will shock young readers because of its very violent beginning, and yet that violence is handled well in the story, and it creates the lasting impression upon young minds that its author intended. For the writer tells the story from the point of view of a dog cruelly abused, his suffering, and his rescue. In a culture where children see a lot of violence, this book is a refreshing truth: violence hurts. It brings pain and grief, and good people still try to heal pain and grief and
BEAUTIFUL JOE will shock young readers because of its very violent beginning, and yet that violence is handled well in the story, and it creates the lasting impression upon young minds that its author intended. For the writer tells the story from the point of view of a dog cruelly abused, his suffering, and his rescue. In a culture where children see a lot of violence, this book is a refreshing truth: violence hurts. It brings pain and grief, and good people still try to heal pain and grief and bring an end to violence.
Younger readers will quickly come to identify with Beautiful Joe, this lonely dog who enters a world of respect, kindness, and care, and blossoms under it. There are a few parts of the book that moralize a bit too much, and some children may need some guidance to understand that the setting of the book is from an era before ours. (Don't be surprised if your young reader asks, "What's a milkman?")
As an adult, and a Christian, reading the book, I find some of Saunders' optimism about the ascent of man incredibly naive. She was a peer of LM Montgomery, writer of Anne of Green Gables, and lacks the subtle and agile pen of Anne's creator. But children will not notice these flaws. And BEAUTIFUL JOE, as an engaging means of showing that animals deserve to be treated with kindness and care, is a worthy book for readers 9-11.
...more
Discovered this book in a cabinet at my Grandparents as a child -- it had belonged to my grandfather -- and read it then and later as a teenager or young adult. Defnitely was a tearjerker! One of the most memorable books of my childhood . . . but then children don't often read about realistic brutality. But the dog's life improves and all's well.
Intend to give a copy to 7-year-old granddaughter -- we'll see if she reacts as I did.
Brilliant read for children. All the characters in the book, except for Jenkins, show compassion and kindness. Joe was taken in by the Morrises, and was treated with much kindness and love. Joe learns from them, and from the other wise animals in the household. Through Joe's perspective, the reader comes across many instances of animal and human kindness.
Excellent childrens book from my youth, another of the many that my grandmother picked up at garage sales. The pages are yellowed and brittle, and the back cover is duct tape and the cardboard backer out of a picture frame (granma dearman's make-shift replacement, lol). For a kids book that was thirty years old when I read it, and almost another thiry years since, I guess it's holding up decent. :D
Anyhow, this book focuses on kindness to animals by way of the title character Beautiful Joe. Full
Excellent childrens book from my youth, another of the many that my grandmother picked up at garage sales. The pages are yellowed and brittle, and the back cover is duct tape and the cardboard backer out of a picture frame (granma dearman's make-shift replacement, lol). For a kids book that was thirty years old when I read it, and almost another thiry years since, I guess it's holding up decent. :D
Anyhow, this book focuses on kindness to animals by way of the title character Beautiful Joe. Full of good advice for children of all ages (including my adult self), this is a great novel for teaching responsibility and manners. Even though some things are a bit dated (it was originally written in 1898, after all), the core of the story holds up well with both a strong female lead and a supporting cast of positive male role models.
Often described as the Canadian version of Black Beauty, Beautiful Joe is a great book for young aspiring animal activists. Saunders was way beyond her time when she wrote on behalf of the humane treatment of a wide variety of animals, from domestic pets like cats and dogs, to farm animals like chickens and cows. Through the voice of a mutt named Beautiful Joe, she draws attention to the injustices done to animals, injustices that still continue today.
As a story itself, I felt it was lacking
Often described as the Canadian version of Black Beauty, Beautiful Joe is a great book for young aspiring animal activists. Saunders was way beyond her time when she wrote on behalf of the humane treatment of a wide variety of animals, from domestic pets like cats and dogs, to farm animals like chickens and cows. Through the voice of a mutt named Beautiful Joe, she draws attention to the injustices done to animals, injustices that still continue today.
As a story itself, I felt it was lacking in some ways. There was no real plot sequence, rather just Joe's recollection of interesting events during his life. It can lean to the preachy side at times, with Saunders (courageously) trying to bring attention to all the ways that animals are hard done by. Nevertheless, a highly readable novel with an important message.
...more
For the most part I liked this book. I enjoyed the Beautiful Joe's narratives of his adventures and those of his animal siblings in the household he came to call home. If the whole book would have been about that I would have loved it more unfortunately it wasn't and I found much of the communication spoken by his humans about animal rights to be rather preachy. Normally I would be all over this because I LOVE animals but it was overbearing at times. I had to keep reminding myself of when the bo
For the most part I liked this book. I enjoyed the Beautiful Joe's narratives of his adventures and those of his animal siblings in the household he came to call home. If the whole book would have been about that I would have loved it more unfortunately it wasn't and I found much of the communication spoken by his humans about animal rights to be rather preachy. Normally I would be all over this because I LOVE animals but it was overbearing at times. I had to keep reminding myself of when the book was written and that was used as training tool for people of that era. My heart broke for all the hardships some of the animals endured in the different stories but there were many others that warmed my heart just as much. It was well written but I will probably not read it again.
...more
My grandmother gave me her copy of this book when I was 11. Her copy was printed in 1934 and it is one of the oldest books I own. The story was very hard for me to read, not because of difficulty with words, but because of the content. Even though it was hard to read I devoured the book during my 18 hour car ride back to my parents house in CA. I finished it before I got home. The book details the life of a dog named Beautiful Joe. He is a 'cur', what we would call a 'mix' or a 'mutt' now, and h
My grandmother gave me her copy of this book when I was 11. Her copy was printed in 1934 and it is one of the oldest books I own. The story was very hard for me to read, not because of difficulty with words, but because of the content. Even though it was hard to read I devoured the book during my 18 hour car ride back to my parents house in CA. I finished it before I got home. The book details the life of a dog named Beautiful Joe. He is a 'cur', what we would call a 'mix' or a 'mutt' now, and he does not have an easy life. The cruelty that Joe goes through was the hardest part for me to read. I do think this is a wonderful story though. I haven't read it since I was 11, but even now, when I am 26, the story still stays with me.
Margaret Marshall Saunders CBE was a Canadian author.
Saunders was born in the village of Milton, Queens County, Nova Scotia. She spent most of her childhood in Berwick, Nova Scotia where her father served as Baptist minister. Saunders is most famous for her novel
Beautiful Joe
. Originally published under the pseudonym Marshall Saunders, it is a story narrated by a dog who has had a difficult puppy
Margaret Marshall Saunders CBE was a Canadian author.
Saunders was born in the village of Milton, Queens County, Nova Scotia. She spent most of her childhood in Berwick, Nova Scotia where her father served as Baptist minister. Saunders is most famous for her novel
Beautiful Joe
. Originally published under the pseudonym Marshall Saunders, it is a story narrated by a dog who has had a difficult puppyhood with many obstacles including a cruel owner. When the book was published in 1894, both it and its subject received worldwide attention. It was the first Canadian book to sell over a million copies, and by the late 1930s had sold over seven million copies worldwide.
In 1934, Saunders was made a Commander of the British Empire (C.B.E.), at the time her country's highest civilian honor. Together with fellow Canadian author, Lucy Maud Montgomery, Saunders co-founded the Maritime branch of the Canadian Women's Press Club.
Following the success of
Beautiful Joe
, Saunders wrote more than twenty other stories, a number of which provided social commentary on such things as the abolition of child labor, slum clearance, and the improvement of playground facilities.
Saunders died in 1947 in Toronto, Ontario where she had lived for a number of years.
...more